Re: g_mem-chunk_destroy does not free memory for GLib > 2.8

[Bill Meier <wmeier () newsguy com>]

While working on bug #2375 I've found out (the hard way) what Didier 
reported in bug #3813:

"... in recent glibs g_mem_chunk_destroy doesn't free [memory] ...".

I'm guessing that this is true for any GLib > 2.8 (altho I haven't 
checked) since GSlice was implemented in GLib 2.10.

This means that any use of a current (recent) GLib GMemChunk  with many 
entries can/will be a memory leak.

For example: I've a 40Meg capture file with NCP frames which causes 
memory allocation to increase by 20 M each time the file is reloaded (^R).
(Loading the file results in 2 memchunks in the NCP222 dissector each 
with over 60K entries).

I note that the GLib doc (under GMemChunk) suggests using the slice 
allocator instead (g_slice_new & etc).

However, unless I'm missing something it seems to me that to free up 
(say) 60K slices requires a loop to call g_slice_free 60K times.

(g_slice_free_chain can be used if the slices are part of a linked list).

If there is no simple way to free up what may be an array of many 
multiple slices, I'm inclined to replace the use of GMemChunk (at least 
for those cases) by the use of GArray.

After a quick look, one concern I have is about constantly extending a 
GArray thus causing a copy each time. I note that it does seem that 
space for multiple entries can be pre-allocated. So: a wrapper for 
GArray could be coded which more or less does what I GMemChunk used to 
do. Or: does GArray have some builtin optimization ?


Comments ?
(or: what am I missing as to the best way to replace the use of 
GMemChunk ?).


Bill



The following GMemChunk usages look like memory leaks (eg: when file 
reloaded):
   ./epan/dissectors/packet-isakmp.c
   ./epan/dissectors/packet-mgcp.c
   ./epan/dissectors/packet-radius.c
   ./epan/dissectors/packet-sbus.c
   ./epan/dissectors/packet-teamspeak2.c
   ./epan/stream.c
   ./plugins/irda/packet-irda.c
   ./plugins/mate/mate_util.c

The following are OK:
   ./epan/proto.c:455  ; Used for all GLib versions: mem leak @
                       ;  proto_cleanup ?
                       ; Benign since proto_cleanup called only @ exit ??
   ./epan/reassemble.c ; uses g_slice if GLib >= 2.10;
                       ;  frees individual slices.
   ./epan/tvbuff.c     ; uses g_slice if GLib >= 2.10;
                       ;  frees individual slices.
   ./file.c            ; use GSlice if GLib >= 2.10;
                       ; frees via g_slice_free_chain
___________________________________________________________________________
Sent via:    Wireshark-dev mailing list <wireshark-dev () wireshark org>
Archives:    http://www.wireshark.org/lists/wireshark-dev
Unsubscribe: https://wireshark.org/mailman/options/wireshark-dev
             mailto:wireshark-dev-request () wireshark org?subject=unsubscribe