Re: ISA Server and SQL Injection

["Jan P. Monsch" <jan.monsch () csnc ch>]

Hi there!

I have lots of discussions with customers regarding the issue of 
perimeter application filters. May conclusion regarding the issue is as 
follows:

1. Validation in the application itself is the best and most efficient 
way of handling code injection problems. Because the application knows 
about its domain but the gateway filter not. In addition the application 
can provide appropriate error messages for incorrect input.

2. Output validation is much better then Input validation, because most 
problems are related to incorrectly encoding input parameters into 
output. In addition proper output encoding allows to use critical 
characters like < > within the application. This is especially important 
in back-office applications.

3. Output validation should be handled in a security framework, built by 
a security expert. It must be implemented such that the business 
developer has not to worry about encoding stuff. (I know this is a ideal 
world szenario)

4. In may opinion validation on the gateway does only make sense if it 
used in a transitional way until input/output validation in the 
application has been implemented or it is used as a part of intrusion 
detection.

Regars Jan