nanog mailing list archives
Re: SDN Internet Router (sir)
From: Masataka Ohta <mohta () necom830 hpcl titech ac jp>
Date: Sat, 7 Jan 2023 18:52:19 +0900
Matthew Walster wrote:
No... It's action based. You can send it a different route, you can replicate it, you can drop it, you can mutate it...
Replication is a poor alternative for multicast. For other actions, why, do you think, they are performed? Just for fun? Or to differentiate treatment of some packets, that is, prioritization?
You can send it to a different destination for stateful filtering when it doesn't match an expected pattern!
Unless pattern is as simple as having certain port number, stateful filtering almost always needs all packets including those matching expected pattern, I'm afraid.
SDN is not just QoS routing, please stop saying that.
See above.
Nope, not true. Had 1000 routes, only 100 available in FIB. So you filter to the top 50 doing traffic and default route the rest of the traffic. Less entries.
If default route is acceptable, just rely on it along with 50 non default routes with plain IP routers. Masataka Ohta
Current thread:
- SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 03)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mel Beckman (Jan 03)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 03)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 03)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Tom Beecher (Jan 04)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Christopher Morrow (Jan 04)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Masataka Ohta (Jan 06)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Matthew Walster via NANOG (Jan 06)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Masataka Ohta (Jan 06)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Matthew Walster via NANOG (Jan 06)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Masataka Ohta (Jan 07)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Matthew Walster via NANOG (Jan 07)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Masataka Ohta (Jan 07)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 10)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 10)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Masataka Ohta (Jan 11)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 11)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) John Osmon (Jan 11)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mel Beckman (Jan 03)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 05)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Tom Beecher (Jan 05)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 05)