nanog mailing list archives
Re: SDN Internet Router (sir)
From: Christopher Morrow <morrowc.lists () gmail com>
Date: Thu, 5 Jan 2023 13:27:08 -0500
On Thu, Jan 5, 2023 at 11:18 AM Mike Hammett <nanog () ics-il net> wrote:
Initially, my thought was to use community filtering to push just IXes, customers, and defaults throughout the network, but that's obviously still sub-optimal. I'd be surprised if a last mile network had a ton of traffic going to any more than a few hundred prefixes.
I think in a low-fib box at the edge of your network your choices are: "the easy choice, get default, follow that" "send some limited set of prefixes to the device, and default, so you MAY choose better for the initial hop away" you certainly can do the second with communities, or route-filters (prefix-list) on the senders, or.... you can choose what prefixes make the cut (get the community(ies)) based on traffic volumes or expected destination locality: "do not go east to go west!" these things will introduce toil and SOME suboptimal routing in some instances... perhaps it's better than per flow choosing left/right though and the support calls related to that choice. In your NOLA / DFW / ATL example it's totally possible that the networks in question do something like: "low fib box in tier-2 city (NOLA), dfz capable/core devices in tier-1 city (DFW/ATL), and send default from left/right to NOLA" Could they send more prefixes than default? sure... do they want to deal with the toil that induces? (probably not says your example). SDN isn't really an answer to this, though.. I don't think. Unless you envision that to lower the toil ?
Current thread:
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir), (continued)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Masataka Ohta (Jan 07)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 10)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 10)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Masataka Ohta (Jan 11)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 11)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) John Osmon (Jan 11)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 05)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Tom Beecher (Jan 05)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 05)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 05)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Christopher Morrow (Jan 05)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 05)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Joe Maimon (Jan 05)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 05)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mel Beckman (Jan 05)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 05)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mel Beckman (Jan 05)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Joe Maimon (Jan 05)
- RE: SDN Internet Router (sir) Chris Wright (Jan 05)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Mike Hammett (Jan 06)
- Re: SDN Internet Router (sir) Tom Beecher (Jan 06)