nanog mailing list archives

Re: do we know what laws apply to Parler


From: "John Levine" <johnl () iecc com>
Date: 10 Jan 2021 21:34:07 -0500

In article <2ab9a074-bb67-4e75-1db1-2c7fff87f0c8 () rollernet us> you write:
On 1/10/21 4:00 PM, Eric S. Raymond wrote:
sronan () ronan-online com <sronan () ronan-online com>:
While Amazon is absolutely within their rights to suspend anyone they want for violation of their TOS, it does 
create an interesting
problem. Amazon is now in the content moderation business, which could potentially open them up to liability if they 
fail to suspend any
other customer who hosts objectionable content.

When I actively hosted USENET servers, I was repeatedly warned by in-house and external counsel, not to moderate 
which groups I
hosted based on content, less I become responsible for moderating all groups, shouldn’t that same principal apply to 
platforms like
AWS and Twitter?

Yes, it would.  This was an astonnishingly stupid move on AWS's part;
I'm prett sure their counsel was not conmsulted.

Surely everyone on this list, purportedly a network operators list, has 
to have at least heard of 47 USC Section 230... right?

Unfortunately, you appear to be wildly overoptimistic.


Current thread: