nanog mailing list archives
Re: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table
From: Mark Tinka <mark.tinka () seacom mu>
Date: Wed, 17 Jun 2020 16:33:44 +0200
On 17/Jun/20 16:25, Jon Lewis wrote:
The flip side of this though is that every time an IP space owner publishes an ROA for an aggregate IP block and overlooks the fact that they have customers BGP originating a subnet of the aggregate with an ASN not permitted by an ROA, HE has "less than a full table". :(
This is a known business use-case and it's incumbent upon the address and AS holders to co-ordinate this. We dropped some prefixes due to this in October of last year. Once we raised the issue with the remote network, it was fixed in 30 minutes.
i.e. I'm questioning whether the system is mature enough and properly used widely enough for dropping RPKI invalids to be a good idea?
Well, if we don't deploy, nothing matures. The problems we hit in the field will help to make the entire system better. Mark.
Current thread:
- Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table Mike Leber via NANOG (Jun 15)
- Re: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table TJ Trout (Jun 15)
- Re: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table Mehmet Akcin (Jun 15)
- Re: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table Saku Ytti (Jun 15)
- Reactive RPKI ROV (Was: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs) Job Snijders (Jun 16)
- Re: Reactive RPKI ROV (Was: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs) Mark Tinka (Jun 17)
- Re: Reactive RPKI ROV (Was: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs) Baldur Norddahl (Jun 17)
- Re: Reactive RPKI ROV (Was: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs) Job Snijders (Jun 17)
- Reactive RPKI ROV (Was: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs) Job Snijders (Jun 16)
- Re: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table TJ Trout (Jun 15)
- Re: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table Saku Ytti (Jun 17)
- Re: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table Mark Tinka (Jun 17)
- RE: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table Tim Warnock (Jun 17)
- Re: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table Mark Tinka (Jun 18)
- Re: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table Nick Hilliard (Jun 18)
- Re: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table Mark Tinka (Jun 18)
- Re: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table Nick Hilliard (Jun 18)
- Re: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table Randy Bush (Jun 17)
- Re: Hurricane Electric has reached 0 RPKI INVALIDs in our routing table Randy Bush (Jun 17)