nanog mailing list archives

Re: Traffic visibility tools


From: Joel Jaeggli <joelja () bogus com>
Date: Wed, 24 Jul 2019 10:14:52 -0700


On 7/24/19 09:16, Kenny Taylor wrote:

Good morning,

 

I hate to pull away from the 44/8 fire (KJ6BSQ here, and former
AMPRnet user), but I’d like to get some advice from the community on
traffic visibility tools..

 

We use a pair of appliances called Exinda for traffic shaping and
visibility.  The current appliances are end-of-support and the
replacements are hugely expensive after GFI acquired Exinda.  Traffic
shaping is less of a concern now, as circuit speeds have caught up
with our users, but visibility is still a big need.  Those boxes do
two things very well:  1) identification of FQDNs using SSL cert
inspection on HTTPS traffic and 2) categorization of the traffic (i.e.
Netflix, Youtube, etc.).  We have Netflow monitoring using PRTG, but
seeing something like
‘ec2-34-214-76-39.us-west-2.compute.amazonaws.com’ in Netflow logs
isn’t very useful.

tls 1.3 encrypted SNI  or QUIC and then DOH will eventually make https
opaque. Whether this is soon or not I guess is an open question but
passive inspection will probably become less useful over time. it seems
likely to cause industry / monitoring product change as well.

We’re looking for something that could sit either inline or hang off a
SPAN port, handle 5-10 Gbit of traffic, do the SSL cert FQDN
identification, and preferably group results by site/subnet/category. 
What would you guys recommend?

 

Thanks,

 

Kenny Taylor

WAN Engineer

Kern Community College District

 

Attachment: pEpkey.asc
Description:


Current thread: