nanog mailing list archives

Re: Last Mile Design


From: Mark Tinka <mark.tinka () seacom mu>
Date: Sat, 9 Feb 2019 09:13:09 +0200



On 8/Feb/19 19:44, Brandon Martin wrote:

 

I'm thinking that, if you push L3 termination all the way out to the
last access node (FTTN DSLAM being the obvious one here), you may then
lack a decent way to haul pure Ethernet back to their head-end.  If
your L3 termination also supports MPLS, or Q-in-Q, you're probably
fine.  The latter might negate the potential advantages of distributed
L3 from a routing POV by forcing you to again run STP or similar.

If you're doing L3 termination a bit more centralized, even if not
with big behemoths on a "one per super-metro" basis, this may not be a
problem at all.  HFC and FTTx PONs might end up being like that
inherently just because of the nature of the plant and tech that runs
on it.

My assumption is that you'd be running full IP/MPLS all the way into the
Access. In that case, what I'm saying is that you can run EoMPLS to
deliver the service.

Mark.


Current thread: