nanog mailing list archives
Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames?
From: joel jaeggli <joelja () bogus com>
Date: Wed, 9 Mar 2016 08:27:13 -0800
On 3/9/16 7:58 AM, Mikael Abrahamsson wrote:
On Wed, 9 Mar 2016, Nick Hilliard wrote:used. Some will want 9000, some 9200, others 4470 and some peopleI have a strong opinion for jumboframes=9180bytes (IPv4/IPv6 MTU), partly because there are two standards referencing this size (RFC 1209 and 1626), and also because all major core router vendors support this size now that Juniper has decided (after some pushing) to start supporting it in more recent software on all their major platforms (before that they had too low L2 MTU to be able to support 9180 L3 MTU). In order to deploy this to end systems, I however thing we're going to need something like https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-van-beijnum-multi-mtu-04 to make this work on mixed-MTU LANs. The whole thing about PMTUD blackhole detection is also going to be needed, so hosts try lower PMTU in case larger packets are dropped because of L2 misconfiguration in networks. With IPv6 we have the chance to make PMTUD work properly and also have
The prospects for that seem relatively dire. of course whats being discussed here is the mixed L2 case, where the device will probably not sent icmp6 ptb anyway but rather simply discard the packet as a giant.
PMTU blackhole detection implemented in all hosts. IPv4 is lost cause in my opinion (although it's strange how many hosts that seem to get away with 1492 (or is it 1496) MTU because they're using PPPoE).
if your adv_mss is set accordingly you can get away with a lot.
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
Current thread:
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames?, (continued)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Mike Hammett (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Kurt Kraut via NANOG (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Stefan Neufeind (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Nick Hilliard (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Mikael Abrahamsson (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? David Bass (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Mikael Abrahamsson (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Nick Hilliard (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? William Herrin (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? joel jaeggli (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Joel Maslak (Mar 10)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Mark Andrews (Mar 12)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Kurt Kraut via NANOG (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Niels Bakker (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Tassos Chatzithomaoglou (Mar 09)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Frank Habicht (Mar 12)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Chris Woodfield (Mar 17)
- Re: Internet Exchanges supporting jumbo frames? Nikolay Shopik (Mar 17)