nanog mailing list archives
Re: New ICANN registrant change process
From: David Conrad <drc () virtualized org>
Date: Wed, 6 Jul 2016 08:53:30 -1000
On Jul 6, 2016, at 7:23 AM, Christopher Morrow <morrowc.lists () gmail com> wrote:
On Mon, Jul 4, 2016 at 3:03 PM, Jay Ashworth <jra () baylink com> wrote:Seems to me that the proper thing to be done would have been for Registries to deauthorize registrars on the grounds of continuous streams of complaints.<devils advocate hat> On what metric? Pure volume? Percent of registrations? type of complaint by similar x/y? </devils advocate hat>
By the terms the Registry sets in the Registry/Registrar Agreement and to which the Registrar agrees in order to sell the Registry's names.
there are 'lots of complaints' against some registrars, but if you have ~20% of the .TLD market you're prone to get more volume than a 1%er, right?
There's this concept called "normalization", e.g., complaints per 100 delegations or some such.
Also, this isn't REALLY the registrY's problem is it?
Depends on whether or not the Registry wants their TLD to be associated with spam/malware distribution/botnet C&C/phishing/pharming and be removed at resolvers via RPZ or similar. Ultimately, the Registries are responsible for the pool the Registrars are peeing in -- it's the Registry's namespace, is it not?
i love how icann makes avoiding blame so easy.
I love how people love to blame ICANN. Regards, -drc (speaking only for myself)
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: Message signed with OpenPGP using GPGMail
Current thread:
- New ICANN registrant change process Jay R. Ashworth (Jul 04)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process Mel Beckman (Jul 04)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process Jay Ashworth (Jul 04)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process Christopher Morrow (Jul 06)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process David Conrad (Jul 06)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process Christopher Morrow (Jul 06)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process David Conrad (Jul 06)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process Christopher Morrow (Jul 06)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process David Conrad (Jul 06)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process Christopher Morrow (Jul 06)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process Jay Ashworth (Jul 04)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process Rubens Kuhl (Jul 06)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process David Conrad (Jul 06)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process Jaap Akkerhuis (Jul 06)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process Rubens Kuhl (Jul 07)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process Mel Beckman (Jul 04)
- Re: New ICANN registrant change process Valdis . Kletnieks (Jul 06)