nanog mailing list archives
Re: FCC releases Open Internet document
From: Lamar Owen <lowen () pari edu>
Date: Thu, 12 Mar 2015 15:25:00 -0400
On 03/12/2015 02:02 PM, Rob McEwen wrote:
On 3/12/2015 1:30 PM, William Kenny wrote:NO BLOCKING: A person engaged in the provision of broadband Internet access service, insofar as such person is so engaged, shall not block lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices, subject to reasonable network management.The document (if I read it correctly) states that "reasonable network management" includes spam filtering.... (yeah!)However, in spite of that... it seems to give the MISTAKEN impression that:(1) ALL spam is ALWAYS... NOT-lawful content (2) ALL lawful content is NEVER spam.
I think the issue is adequately addressed by the R&O's paragraph 222 and its neighbors, with footnotes 571, 572, and 573 elucidating. The short version: the FCC is not going to rigidly define this and leave it up to the providers, but they will address it on a case-by-case basis if need be. At least that was my takeaway.
Nevertheless, in such a circumstance, 47 USC 230(c)(2) should prevail and trump any such interpretation of this!It would seem, but I am not a lawyer, that perhaps it would. It's not directly addressed in the portions of the R&O that I've read thus far, and that specific paragraph is not cited that I could find. A Good Samaritan law, in 47 USC..... fun stuff.(If anyone thinks that 47 USC 230(c)(2) might not prevail over such an interpretation, please let me know... and let me know why?)
Current thread:
- FCC releases Open Internet document Ca By (Mar 12)
- Re: FCC releases Open Internet document shawn wilson (Mar 12)
- Re: FCC releases Open Internet document William Kenny (Mar 12)
- Re: FCC releases Open Internet document Rob McEwen (Mar 12)
- Re: FCC releases Open Internet document Lamar Owen (Mar 12)
- Re: FCC releases Open Internet document Lamar Owen (Mar 12)
- Re: FCC releases Open Internet document Mike A (Mar 12)
- RE: FCC releases Open Internet document Hass, Douglas A. (Mar 12)
- Re: FCC releases Open Internet document William Kenny (Mar 12)
- Re: FCC releases Open Internet document shawn wilson (Mar 12)
- Re: FCC releases Open Internet document Bryan Tong (Mar 12)
- Re: FCC releases Open Internet document Lamar Owen (Mar 12)
- Re: FCC releases Open Internet document Lamar Owen (Mar 12)
- Re: FCC releases Open Internet document Livingood, Jason (Mar 12)