RE: Verizon Policy Statement on Net Neutrality

["Naslund, Steve" <SNaslund () medline com>]

> ::AWOOOOGAAAA:: Strawman Alert!
>
> Nobody's talking about taking poor Erlang behind the barn and shooting him.
>
> We're talking about being able to send upstream at a reasonable/comparable rate as downstream.
>
>
> Mike

Exactly, now you see the dilemma.  What is reasonable/comparable?  Is it reasonable to assume that users upload as much 
as they download when every traffic study I have ever done or seen tells me that is not the case?  Is it reasonable for 
me to allocate my customers to 5M down/5M up when they really mostly use 8.5 down/1.5 up?   I know it would make you 
happy to build my network so that you can twiddle the upload/download dials but is it reasonable to make all of my 
customers pay for that infrastructure rather than ask you to buy a more premium business class service if you want that?

Steven Naslund
Chicago IL