nanog mailing list archives
Re: Is it unusual to remove defunct rr objects?
From: Rob Seastrom <rs () seastrom com>
Date: Sat, 01 Nov 2014 18:18:41 -0400
Jimmy Hess <mysidia () gmail com> writes:
Do the internet route registries exist to track routes that are not to appear on the public internet? I think not.
What's "the public Internet"? Does it mean "the DFZ as seen at Jimmy Hess' router, with his set of upstreams"? If so, I can assure you that there are plenty of routes that need to pass filters that are (or optimally would be) built off of IRR data that would not pass this test.
There should probably be an attribute provided for such objects, however, that would indicate "This route does not appear on the public internet".
see above. :)
If not tagged like that in some manner, and a matching route does has not appeared on the public internet at any time during the past 6 to 12 months, then I would consider the registry object to be defunct.
Where on the public Internet? Do networks run by organizations such as SITA, ARINC, BT Radianz, UK MOD, and US DOD that use globally unique space and may interconnect with each other in some way (and could hypothetically be using IRR-type structures to describe that routing policy though I don't think the military does that) get their objects unceremoniously booted? -r
Current thread:
- Re: Is it unusual to remove defunct rr objects? Randy Bush (Oct 31)
- Re: Is it unusual to remove defunct rr objects? Jared Mauch (Nov 01)
- Re: Is it unusual to remove defunct rr objects? Jimmy Hess (Nov 01)
- Re: Is it unusual to remove defunct rr objects? Rob Seastrom (Nov 01)
- Re: Is it unusual to remove defunct rr objects? Baldur Norddahl (Nov 02)
- Re: Is it unusual to remove defunct rr objects? Rob Seastrom (Nov 02)
- Re: Is it unusual to remove defunct rr objects? Jimmy Hess (Nov 01)
- Re: Is it unusual to remove defunct rr objects? Jared Mauch (Nov 01)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: Is it unusual to remove defunct rr objects? Ca By (Nov 01)
- Re: Is it unusual to remove defunct rr objects? Tim Howe (Nov 01)