nanog mailing list archives

Re: Net Neutrality...


From: Doug Barton <dougb () dougbarton us>
Date: Tue, 15 Jul 2014 14:20:06 -0700

Brett,

You've more or less accurately described the reality of the situation. Please feel free to proceed with the "dealing with it" suggestion that I also made as part of the post you responded to. :)

Good luck,

Doug


On 07/15/2014 01:42 PM, Brett Glass wrote:
At 01:24 PM 7/15/2014, Doug Barton wrote:

Just off the top of my head ....

More than one person in a location, and they are watching different
shows.

How many do you allow for per household? Do they want to pay to be able
to saturate everyone's senses simultaneously, with different
programming, at any time? (We can do that, but it will cost more.)

This is a classic example of the oversubscription problem that I and
others have described on numerous previous occasions, several of which
have occurred since you joined the list. Your customers are using the
service they are paying you to provide in a way that makes your life
more difficult.

Having customers use the service I sell them does not make my life more
difficult. I state very clearly what they are paying for: a certain
guaranteed minimum capacity, to a certain point on the Internet
backbone, with a certain maximum duty cycle. I can (and often do) take
spot measurements of the amount of capacity they are using, tell them
how much they are using, and verify that they are getting what they pay
for. If they want more, they can always purchase it.

The things that are making my life difficult at the moment include the
following:

* Government agencies attempting to impose requirements upon us and then
denying us the resources we need to fulfill them;

* Government agencies trying to dictate what users can buy rather than
allowing them to choose;

* Corporations exploiting market power or attempting to use the
government so as to tilt the playing field in their favor; and

* Corporations lying to consumers so as to get them to blame me for
their own failings.

If I quit the business, it won't be because I don't care about my
customers or love what I do. It'll be because government and
corporations have put so many roadblocks in my way that I can no longer
deliver.

--Brett Glass



Current thread: