Re: Per Site QOS policy with Cisco IOS-XE

[Wes Tribble <westribble () gmail com>]

Tyler,

Tyler,

I already had a case open with TAC on this issue.  This is what the CCIE
assigned to the case is saying about that type of policy:


Hi Wesley,


Yes, I’m afraid that configuration is not possible. We can only mark or
police traffic on this child policy.



You will see the following message when trying to attach the service-policy
to the interface:



---

ASR10004(config-if)#service-policy output parent_shaper
Cannot attach queuing-based child policy to a non-queuing based class

*This is what I sent to her:*

 So this configuration is not possible?

policy-map parent_shaper
 class class-default
 shape average 100000000 < --- 100Mbps parent shaper.
 service-policy site_shaper

policy-map site_shaper
 class t1_site
  shape average 1536000
  service-policy qos_global
 class multilink_site
  shape average 3072000
  service-policy qos_global
  class class-default
  service-policy qos_global

policy-map qos_global
 class VOICE
  priority percent 25
  set dscp ef
 class AF41
  bandwidth percent 40
  set dscp af41
  queue-limit 1024 packets
 class class-default
  fair-queue
  set dscp af21
  queue-limit 1024 packets

On Thu, May 9, 2013 at 8:33 AM, Tyler Haske <tyler.haske () gmail com> wrote:

>  Wes,
>
> The earlier policy doesn't use bandwidth commands, hence, it doesn't
> *subscribe* anything. The only thing it does is ensures that individual
> sites do not exceed their shaped rate. You could add bandwidth statements
> if you wanted to ensure a certain site always is guaranteed a certain
> amount of bandwidth from the parent shaper. You can't oversubscribe with
> the bandwidth command.
>
>
> policy-map parent_shaper
>  class class-default
>   shape average 100000000
>    service-policy site_shaper
>
> policy-map site_shaper
>  class t1_site
>   shape average 1536000
>   bandwidth percent 1
>
>    service-policy qos_global
>  class multilink_site
>   shape average 3072000
>   bandwidth percent 2
>    service-policy qos_global
>  class class-default
>   bandwidth percent 97
>    service-policy qos_global
>
> policy-map qos_global
>  ! ... whatever you want here.
>
> This would make sure that large sites don't stare out small spoke sites
> for bandwidth.
>
>  On Thu, May 9, 2013 at 8:58 AM, Wes Tribble <westribble () gmail com> wrote:
>
> > Thanks for the information Tyler, I will have to play around with that
> > kind of policy in my lab.  What would you suggest if you are
> > oversubscribing the interface?  With the child policy inheriting the
> > bandwith of the parent shaper, wouldn't I run out of bandwidth allocation
> > before I built all the shapers for all of my 29 sites?