nanog mailing list archives
Re: home network monitoring and shaping
From: Michael Thomas <mike () mtcc com>
Date: Wed, 13 Feb 2013 09:40:42 -0800
On 02/12/2013 04:46 PM, Joel Maslak wrote:
Large buffers have broken the average home internet. I can't tell you how many people are astonished when I say "one of your family members downloading a huge Microsoft ISO image (via TCP or other congestion-aware algorithm) shouldn't even be noticed by another family member doing web browsing. If it is noticed, the network is broke. Even if it's at the end of a slow DSL line."
This is true only to a point: if you have 5 people streaming movies on a 2 people broadband you're going to have problems regardless of the queuing discipline. That said, it's pretty awful that in this day and age that router vendors can't be bothered to set the default linux kernel queuing parameters to something reasonable. In any case, my point was really about wanting to deal with what happens when your isp bandwidth is saturated and being able to track it down and/or kill off the offenders. I haven't bought a router in the last year or two as "apps" have become de rigueur, but it sure seems like it would be nice to be able to do that. I'm pretty sure that I still can't (= being a dumb consumer, not a net geek jockey), but would like to hear otherwise. Mike
Current thread:
- home network monitoring and shaping Michael Thomas (Feb 12)
- RE: home network monitoring and shaping Warren Bailey (Feb 12)
- Re: home network monitoring and shaping Michael Thomas (Feb 12)
- Re: home network monitoring and shaping Eric Adler (Feb 12)
- Re: home network monitoring and shaping James Harrison (Feb 12)
- Re: home network monitoring and shaping Joel Maslak (Feb 12)
- Re: home network monitoring and shaping Michael Thomas (Feb 13)
- Re: home network monitoring and shaping Sean Lazar (Feb 13)
- Re: home network monitoring and shaping Joel Maslak (Feb 12)
- Re: home network monitoring and shaping Roy (Feb 12)
- Re: home network monitoring and shaping Lee (Feb 12)
- RE: home network monitoring and shaping Warren Bailey (Feb 12)
- Re: home network monitoring and shaping g () 1337 io (Feb 12)