Re: Network device command line interfaces

[Alex Harrowell <a.harrowell () gmail com>]

Ray Soucy <rps () maine edu> wrote:

> One of the biggest benefits to a CLI is the ability to easily script
> tasks.
> In a Cisco environment I can roll out major changes to hundreds of
> switches in seconds, for example.
>
> A lot of network vendors have been trying to make network devices more
> simple and easier to use while the complexity of networking has gone
> up.
> Seems like the wrong direction to me.  If someone wants a managed
> switch,
> they probably intend to manage it.
>
> I think a big key to the success of Cisco (and Juniper, etc) has been
> that
> they "get it" in this respect.
>
> Even companies like Vyatta have invested time in a Web UI rather than
> expanding the core functionality offered (multicast routing support,
> for
> example), which doesn't seem like the best idea.
>
> On Wed, Nov 23, 2011 at 11:41 PM, Jonathon Exley <
> Jonathon.Exley () kordia co nz> wrote:
>
> > Does anyone else despair at the CLIs produced by networking vendors?
> > Real routers use a CLI that is command based, like IOS, TiMOS or
> Junos.
> > These interfaces work well over low bandwidth connections (unlike web
> > interfaces), can work with config backup systems like RANCID, have a
> > (mostly) consistent structure and good show commands.
> > However vendors of low cost routers/switches/muxes seem to take a
> stab in
> > the dark and produce some really nasty stuff. I have a personal hate
> of
> > text based menus and binary config backup files.
> > Doe this p*** off anyone else? The business part of the company says
> "This
> > device is great! It's cheap and does everything." However the poor
> sap who
> > is given the task to make it work has to wrestle with a badly
> designed user
> > interface and illogical syntax.
> > Maybe the vendors need some sort of best practices guide for what
> > manageability features their kit needs to support to make them
> acceptable
> > to the market. Does anyone know if there is anything along these
> lines?
> > Jonathon.
> >
> >
> > This email and attachments: are confidential; may be protected by
> > privilege and copyright; if received in error may not be used,
> copied, or
> > kept; are not guaranteed to be virus-free; may not express the views
> of
> > Kordia(R); do not designate an information system; and do not give
> rise to
> > any liability for Kordia(R).
>
>
>
> -- 
> Ray Soucy
>
> Epic Communications Specialist
>
> Phone: +1 (207) 561-3526
>
> Networkmaine, a Unit of the University of Maine System
> http://www.networkmaine.net/


If you've done a proper CLI, you can easily do a good REST API. If you've done that a good Web GUI is possible. 

It doesn't work the other way round.

-- 
Sent from my Android phone with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.