Re: Nortel, in bankruptcy, sells IPv4 address block for $7.5 million

[Michael DeMan <nanog () deman com>]

On Mar 25, 2011, at 12:05 PM, Owen DeLong wrote:

> On Mar 24, 2011, at 10:08 AM, Randy Bush wrote:
>
> > > > > They can only get them _at all_ if they can document need.  All
> > > > > receipt of address space, whether from the free-pool or through a
> > > > > transfer, is needs-based.  Anything else would be removing a critical
> > > > > resource from use.
> > > > http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canute
> > > Thank you Randy.  Give Canute a community-developed set of marching
> > > orders, and make the ocean a little more pliable and you might have 
> > > something there.
> >
> > at some point, the arin policy wonk weenies will face reality.  or not.
> > it really makes little difference.  
> >
> > i don't particularly like the reality either, but i find it easier and
> > more productive to align my actions and how i spend my time.  not a lot
> > of high paying jobs pushing water uphill.
> >
> > randy
>
> At some point we will see which reality actually pans out. Both the perspective
> of we "ARIN Policy wonk weenies" as Randy so kindly calls us, and, Randy's
> perspective are speculations about future events. I think both are probably equally
> based in reality based on different sets of experiences.
>
> Since my reality has the potential to preserve many good aspects of the internet,
> I hope it turns out that Randy is the one who is wrong.
>
> Owen

Or possibly, if we can not sort this on our own and set a good precedent (for ARIN and the other registries as well) 
that we can sort this out ourselves in a way that is agreeable and beneficial to all stakeholders - we will just be 
adding another piece of lumber onto the ready-to-light bonfire that government needs to step in somehow?
 
- Mike