nanog mailing list archives
Re: Another v6 question
From: Mark Smith <nanog () 85d5b20a518b8f6864949bd940457dc124746ddc nosense org>
Date: Sun, 30 Jan 2011 21:31:25 +1030
On Thu, 27 Jan 2011 09:20:01 -0600 Max Pierson <nmaxpierson () gmail com> wrote:
I'm not missing your point. I'm saying that in IPv6, we've put enoughaddressesin to allow for things nobody has thought of in 30, 60, 90, even 100 yearsandthen some.As Roland said, "Possibly, as long as we don't blow through them via exercises in profligacy nobody has heretofore thought of, heh."If I knew, then, I'd be well on my way to much greater wealth. Whatever itis, I am onlycertain of the following things about it: 1. We have no idea what the requirements will be at this time.I believe it was Donald Rumsfeld that said... "But there are also unknown unknowns – the ones we don't know we don't know." What if that unknown comes in the form of "mass address consumption"? But from your view, that's not possible, so i'll just move on.
We know both what the IPv6 addressing architecture is and what the current IANA/RIR etc. addressing policies are - nothing is an "unknown unknown". *Unexpected* "mass address consumption" is not possible unless and until the current addressing policies change. It is only those who wish to play thought games with how they could abuse 128 bit addresses that are pretending these architectural decisions and policies don't exist and won't be enforced. Mark
Current thread:
- Re: Another v6 question, (continued)
- Re: Another v6 question bmanning (Jan 25)
- Re: Another v6 question Owen DeLong (Jan 25)
- Re: Another v6 question Max Pierson (Jan 25)
- Re: Another v6 question Owen DeLong (Jan 25)
- Re: Another v6 question Max Pierson (Jan 25)
- Re: Another v6 question Owen DeLong (Jan 26)
- Re: Another v6 question Max Pierson (Jan 27)
- Re: Another v6 question Owen DeLong (Jan 26)
- Re: Another v6 question Roland Dobbins (Jan 26)
- Re: Another v6 question Max Pierson (Jan 27)
- Re: Another v6 question Mark Smith (Jan 30)
- Re: Another v6 question bmanning (Jan 25)
- Re: Another v6 question Jared Mauch (Jan 27)
- Re: Another v6 question Owen DeLong (Jan 27)
- /64 is "enough" until 2021 for 90% of users (was Re: Another v6 question) Jared Mauch (Jan 27)
- Re: /64 is "enough" until 2021 for 90% of users (was Re: Another v6 question) Mark Smith (Jan 30)
- Re: Another v6 question Valdis . Kletnieks (Jan 27)
- Re: Another v6 question Mikael Abrahamsson (Jan 27)
- Re: Another v6 question Owen DeLong (Jan 27)
- Re: Another v6 question Per Carlson (Jan 28)
- Re: Another v6 question Mark Andrews (Jan 28)
- Re: Another v6 question Jimmy Hess (Jan 27)