nanog mailing list archives

Re: My upstream ISP does not support IPv6


From: Joel Jaeggli <joelja () bogus com>
Date: Sun, 13 Feb 2011 18:18:10 -0800

fwiw we have v6 transit from internap in metro atlanta. setup was
drama-free. up until about 6 months ago it was offered on a
non-production basis and only as a tunnel, now it's dual stacked to our
customer edge.

joel

On 2/4/11 7:05 AM, Scott Helms wrote:
We have been working diligently for more than 6 months to try and get a
/56 routed to one of our offices in metro Atlanta.  The carrier in
question is a Tier 1 as well as being one of the old telecom names.  I
have the entire chain of emails documenting the carrier's struggles with
internal process and technical issues.  We are currently waiting for a
new edge router to be ready to transfer our existing circuits to.  Not
that it matters but we were also told that we would be moved from a
Cisco to a Juniper.  Once I realized how much of a struggle that was
turning into I contacted some of our other providers (a mix of Tier 1 &
2 ISPs and collocation providers) as of this moment none of them (though
some seem close) are actually prepared to deliver IPv6 connectivity
where we need it despite some of them already touting preparedness.

What I think is worth remembering is that there are a _lot_ of moving
parts to get right to actually route an IPv6 block down a connection. 
Some of those parts are technical like making sure an edge router that
may have been in place for years can handle IPv6 traffic _and_ that
addition won't cause a CPU or other issue on the specific platform
you're looking at.  Some of the others are simply business process
pieces like making sure contracts, internal and external documentation,
and work flow that need to be updated.

TLDR version, marketing often fails to reflect reality :)

On 2/3/2011 10:04 PM, Franck Martin wrote:
The biggest complaint that I hear from ISPs, is that their upstream
ISP does not support IPv6 or will not provide them with a native IPv6
circuit.

Is that bull?

I thought the whole backbone is IPv6 now, and it is only the
residential ISPs that are still figuring it out because CPE are still
not there yet.

Where can I get more information? Any list of peering ISPs that have
IPv6 as part of their products?

It seems to me the typical answer sales people say when asked about
IPv6: "Gosh, this is the first time I'm asked this one".






Current thread: