nanog mailing list archives
Re: Who controlls the Internet?
From: "Patrick W. Gilmore" <patrick () ianai net>
Date: Mon, 26 Jul 2010 10:00:01 -0400
On Jul 25, 2010, at 11:41 PM, Robert West wrote:
Each individual government seems to control the information the enters or leaves their borders.
No, each individual government can have laws restricting information entering and leaving their borders. Few gov'ts actually control said info. The US gov't most certainly does not (despite the tin-foil-hat brigades protestations to the contrary).
Do a search for "Internet Censorship Wikileaks". Every government has their own set of morals and standards and politically motivated black list. Certainly the USA wants to swagger and force its will on not only its own people but the entire planet, but they are not alone.
Nice political blather. What has it got to do on the point at hand. (Also, I would be very happy if every gov't on the planet were as open with information exchange / lax on information control as the USG is.)
Australia, China, North Korea, Germany........ Etc............ All with their own agenda. It would be great if there was ONE entity that controlled content and each country had to abide by their decisions in order to have access to the backbone but that's only just a dream at this point. The flat earth that should be the flow of information needs to be demanded by everyone.
I believe someone else explained just how stupid an idea that was. So I will just add my voice to the idea that multiple unrelated entities running the 'Net is much better than a single, central control. -- TTFN, patrick
Current thread:
- Re: ICANN bashing (was Re: Who controlls the Internet?), (continued)
- Re: ICANN bashing (was Re: Who controlls the Internet?) bmanning (Jul 26)
- Re: ICANN bashing (was Re: Who controlls the Internet?) David Conrad (Jul 26)
- Re: Who controlls the Internet? Fred Baker (Jul 25)
- Re: Who controlls the Internet? bmanning (Jul 25)
- Re: Who controlls the Internet? Joly MacFie (Jul 25)
- RE: Who controlls the Internet? Allen Bass (Jul 25)
- FW: Who controlls the Internet? Robert West (Jul 25)
- Re: Who controlls the Internet? Marshall Eubanks (Jul 26)
- Re: Who controlls the Internet? Jared Hirst (Jul 26)
- Re: FW: Who controlls the Internet? Cian Brennan (Jul 26)
- Re: Who controlls the Internet? Patrick W. Gilmore (Jul 26)
- Re: Who controlls the Internet? Marshall Eubanks (Jul 26)
- FW: Who controlls the Internet? Robert West (Jul 25)
- Re: Who controlls the Internet? Randy Bush (Jul 25)
- Re: Who controlls the Internet? Marshall Eubanks (Jul 26)
- Re: Who controlls the Internet? Gadi Evron (Jul 26)
- Re: Who controlls the Internet? Franck Martin (Jul 26)
- RE: Who controlls the Internet? Tarig Yassin (Jul 25)
- Re: Who controlls the Internet? Josh Hoppes (Jul 25)
- RE: Who controlls the Internet? Justin M. Streiner (Jul 25)
- Re: Who controlls the Internet? Robert Bonomi (Jul 25)
- RE: Who controlls the Internet? Robert West (Jul 25)