nanog mailing list archives
RE: Multi site BGP Routing design
From: "Ivan Pepelnjak" <ip () ioshints info>
Date: Tue, 9 Jun 2009 22:45:59 +0200
I am thinking the multiple ASN route is the cleanest but the idea of letting a default gateway (via static route maybe) out the local upstream connection to reach the other site when the backnet link is down sounds like it would work with minimal to no headaches but it just some how seems like a duct tape job. Does this sort of technique have any significant flaws or concerns associated with it?
It's a static route, so you're never sure the remote end (upstream router) is truly alive. In this respect, it would be much better to receive default route over BGP (if the upstream carrier is willing to implement it). On the other hand, it's a last-resort mechanism, so you'd only use it if everything else fails (and you don't care how reliable it is). Just make sure it's well documented and understood ... and think about what will happen when you add a third carrier to one of the sites. Last but not least, you could use reliable static routing (static route tied to ping tests). http://blog.ioshints.info/2007/02/reliable-static-routing.html http://blog.ioshints.info/search?q=static+routing Just my $0.002 :) Ivan http://www.ioshints.info/about http://blog.ioshints.info/
Current thread:
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design, (continued)
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design Chris Adams (Jun 05)
- RE: Multi site BGP Routing design John.Herbert (Jun 05)
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design Steve Bertrand (Jun 05)
- RE: Multi site BGP Routing design John.Herbert (Jun 05)
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design Chris Adams (Jun 05)
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design Michael K. Smith (Jun 05)
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design Steve Bertrand (Jun 05)
- RE: Multi site BGP Routing design Ivan Pepelnjak (Jun 06)
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design Saqib Ilyas (Jun 06)
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design Adam Greene (Jun 06)
- RE: Multi site BGP Routing design Justin Krejci (Jun 08)
- RE: Multi site BGP Routing design Ivan Pepelnjak (Jun 09)
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design Steve Bertrand (Jun 05)
- RE: Multi site BGP Routing design John.Herbert (Jun 05)
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design Chuck Anderson (Jun 05)
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design Steve Bertrand (Jun 05)
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design Randy Bush (Jun 05)
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design Steve Bertrand (Jun 05)
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design Randy Bush (Jun 05)
- Re: Multi site BGP Routing design Randy Bush (Jun 05)