nanog mailing list archives
Re: So why don't US citizens get this?
From: Hyunseog Ryu <r.hyunseog () ieee org>
Date: Mon, 28 Jul 2008 10:08:36 -0500
I think it is simply the matter of ROI - Return on Investment - issue. I'm still living in the area without city water, and when there is power outage, I don't have water at all since my water pump still needs electricity. But some rural area has FTTH because of government funding RUS (http://www.usda.gov/rus/) project. And most of urban area, people are still happy with cable modem service. People in Japan and South Korea are more of tendency to become early-adapters. So when they have new products, they wants to try it by majority. But in U.S., we are still cost oriented, and if we don't need it, we don't buy it. ^^ That's my 2 cents. Hyun Tom Vest wrote:
Sort of makes one wonder how the US came to have ubiquitous roads, or power, or water distribution... TV On Jul 28, 2008, at 1:06 PM, Jorge Amodio wrote:Lets put aside for a moment the conspiracy theories of government intervention and the telcos evil doing, IMHO there is a simple reason why I don't have fiber going to my house: geography & economics. Japan: - area = 377,873 Km^2 - density = 337/Km^2 - pop = 127.5 mill USA:: - area = 9,826,630 Km^2 - density = 31/Km^2 - pop = 304.7 mill I belive there are just few major cities in the US that have a comparable or higher concentration of people like other large cities around the world. I'd bet that if you deploy fiber in a given radious in a suburban area in Japan you may reach hundreds or thousands of potential customers, do the same a little bit north from where I live and you will reach a dozen guys, 50 cows and a couple of hundred chickens. The US is so spread out that anything to do with transportation, being people, packages, or ip packets becomes quite costly. Still I beleve is interesting to analyze why the US is lagging behind on high speed services. My .02
Current thread:
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this?, (continued)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Jorge Amodio (Jul 28)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Tom Vest (Jul 28)
- RE: [SPAM] Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Ray Plzak (Jul 28)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? John Levine (Jul 28)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Laird Popkin (Jul 28)
- RE: So why don't US citizens get this? Rod Beck (Jul 28)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Scott McGrath (Jul 28)
- RE: So why don't US citizens get this? Rod Beck (Jul 28)
- RE: So why don't US citizens get this? Rod Beck (Jul 28)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Jorge Amodio (Jul 28)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Laurence F. Sheldon, Jr. (Jul 28)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Hyunseog Ryu (Jul 28)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Mikael Abrahamsson (Jul 28)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Michal Krsek (Jul 28)
- RE: So why don't US citizens get this? michael.dillon (Jul 28)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Jack Bates (Jul 28)
- RE: So why don't US citizens get this? michael.dillon (Jul 28)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Jean-François Mezei (Jul 28)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Josh Cheney (Jul 28)
- RE: So why don't US citizens get this? Frank Bulk (Jul 28)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Charles Wyble (Jul 28)
- Re: So why don't US citizens get this? Jorge Amodio (Jul 28)