nanog mailing list archives
Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break
From: Robert Blayzor <rblayzor () inoc net>
Date: Sun, 24 Jun 2007 08:32:48 -0400
Leo Bicknell wrote:
Sorry, it doesn't work like that. I do happen to believe rather than get a single SONET/WDM protected 10G Wave you are better off getting two unprotected 10G waves and plugging them into your devices, and let layer 3 routing take over. It generally saves a good bit of cost, and it helps you keep the cable system honest. You know when there is an outage, no way to hide it from you.
That really depends. Two unprotected circuits are going to cost you twice as much. Typically if you're paying for protection, you're not getting two wavelengths, you're just getting electronics protection in the providers network; unless you've purchased the circuit "route diverse" on separate fiber paths. Protected in some networks doesn't always mean "route diverse".
However, if you put 15G down your "20G" path, you have no redundancy. In a cut, dropping 5G on the floor, causing 33% packet loss is not "up", it might as well be down.
I don't know if that's always true. Case in point 802.17. It runs active-active in unprotected space. While you have the extra bandwidth and classes of service, a cut doesn't really mean you're hard down, it all depends on the SLA's you provide to customers. Of course anything over the guaranteed bandwidth during failure would be classed only as "best effort". -- Robert Blayzor INOC rblayzor () inoc net http://www.inoc.net/~rblayzor/ If you unplug it fast enough, anything is hot swappable!
Current thread:
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break, (continued)
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Jim Popovitch (Jun 22)
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Steve Gibbard (Jun 22)
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Roderick S. Beck (Jun 22)
- RE: TransAtlantic Cable Break Neil J. McRae (Jun 22)
- RE: TransAtlantic Cable Break Roderick S. Beck (Jun 22)
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Hank Nussbacher (Jun 22)
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Sean Donelan (Jun 22)
- RE: TransAtlantic Cable Break Rod Beck (Jun 22)
- Message not available
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Simon Leinen (Jun 24)
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Robert Blayzor (Jun 24)
- Message not available
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Robert Blayzor (Jun 24)
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Chris L. Morrow (Jun 24)
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Robert Blayzor (Jun 24)
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Chris L. Morrow (Jun 24)
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Sean Donelan (Jun 25)
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Christian Kuhtz (Jun 25)
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Deepak Jain (Jun 26)
- Re: TransAtlantic Cable Break Iljitsch van Beijnum (Jun 24)
- RE: TransAtlantic Cable Break Roderick S. Beck (Jun 22)
- RE: TransAtlantic Cable Break Chris L. Morrow (Jun 22)