nanog mailing list archives
Re: UK ISPs v. US ISPs (was RE: Network Level Content Blocking)
From: John Levine <johnl () iecc com>
Date: 12 Jun 2007 00:02:26 -0000
So, although it should be noted that by and large ISPs have resisted being classified telecommunications common carriers as specifically defined in CA1934 they seem to be treated by the law, in practice, as common carriers in the common law sense ...
You're right, but the legal setup is flipped around. For a common carrier of whatever variety, the assumption is that they're not responsible for the contents of what they carry, and there's exceptions for obviously dangerous goods, warrants, etc. For ISPs, the assumption is that they're just normal businesses, and there's laws like the CDA that give immunity for various kinds of customer material. R's, John PS:
It's a very important if somewhat confusing distinction. It'd be a lot easier if we could come up with separate terms for common law common carrier versis CA1934 telecommunications common carrier.
Agreed.
Current thread:
- Re: Network Level Content Blocking (UK) for people who cant be bothered to read the article.., (continued)
- UK ISPs v. US ISPs (was RE: Network Level Content Blocking) Sean Donelan (Jun 09)
- Re: UK ISPs v. US ISPs (was RE: Network Level Content Blocking) Keegan . Holley (Jun 09)
- Re: UK ISPs v. US ISPs (was RE: Network Level Content Blocking) Mark Smith (Jun 11)
- Re: UK ISPs v. US ISPs (was RE: Network Level Content Blocking) Keegan . Holley (Jun 11)
- Re: UK ISPs v. US ISPs (was RE: Network Level Content Blocking) Kradorex Xeron (Jun 09)
- Re: UK ISPs v. US ISPs (was RE: Network Level Content Blocking) Stephen Sprunk (Jun 09)
- Re: UK ISPs v. US ISPs (was RE: Network Level Content Blocking) John Levine (Jun 11)
- Re: UK ISPs v. US ISPs (was RE: Network Level Content Blocking) Barry Shein (Jun 11)
- Re: UK ISPs v. US ISPs (was RE: Network Level Content Blocking) John Levine (Jun 11)
- Re: UK ISPs v. US ISPs (was RE: Network Level Content Blocking) Roland Perry (Jun 12)
- Duties of US ISPs Sean Donelan (Jun 12)
- Re: UK ISPs v. US ISPs (was RE: Network Level Content Blocking) William Allen Simpson (Jun 09)
- Re: UK ISPs v. US ISPs (was RE: Network Level Content Blocking) Alexander Harrowell (Jun 09)