Re: How should ISPs notify customers about Bots (Was Re: DNS Hijacking

[Roland Dobbins <rdobbins () cisco com>]

On Jul 24, 2007, at 8:59 AM, Joe Greco wrote:

> But, hey, it can be done, and with an amount of effort that isn't  
> substantially different from the
> amount of work Cox would have had to do to accomplish what they did.

Actually, it's requires a bit more planning and effort, especially if  
one gets into sinkholing and then reinjecting, which necessitates  
breaking out of the /32 routing loop post-analysis/-proxy.  It can  
and is done, but performing DNS poisoning with an irchoneyd setup is  
quite a bit easier.  And in terms of the amount of traffic headed  
towards the IRC servers in question - the miscreants DDoS one  
another's C&C servers all the time, so it pays to be careful what one  
sinkholes, backhauls, and re-injects not only in terms of current  
traffic, but likely traffic.

In large networks, scale is also a barrier to deployment.  Leveraging  
DNS can provide a pretty large footprint over the entire topology for  
less effort, IMHO.

Also, it appears (I've no firsthand knowledge of this, only the same  
public discussions everyone else has seen) that the goal wasn't just  
to classify possibly-botted hosts, but to issue self-destruct  
commands for several bot variations which support this functionality.

[Note:  This is not intended as commentary as to whether or not the  
DNS poisoning in question was a Good or Bad Idea, just on the delta  
of effort and other operational considerations of DNS poisoning vs.  
sinkholing/re-injection.]

Public reports that both Cox and Time-Warner performed this activity  
nearly simultaneously; was it a coordinated effort?  Was this a one- 
time, short-term measure to try and de-bot some hosts?  Does anyone  
have any insight as to whether this exercise has resulted in less  
undesirable activity on the networks in question?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Roland Dobbins <rdobbins () cisco com> // 408.527.6376 voice

       Culture eats strategy for breakfast.

               -- Ford Motor Company