nanog mailing list archives

Re: Measurement data on transit traffic in IP routers?


From: Frank Coluccio <frank () dticonsulting com>
Date: Mon, 19 Feb 2007 09:25:50 -0600


Your statement makes something of a presumption
as to the architecture of a network.  In many 
networks, edge aggregation devices do not
participate in backbone routing, but simply 
pass the traffic they are aggregating into the core.

My first reaction, as well. However, I was reminded 
by Andrew Odlyzko that the cable tv industry's (MSOs')
peering universe constitute a form of flattened 'edge', 
if one were to consider the larger Internet's core 
against the MSO community, which makes for another 
form of interesting analysis, since much of today's
(especially more capacious) residential "broadband"
flows begin and end on MSOs' networks, and sometimes 
never touch the larger core, fwiw. And this opens the
door to other forms of "walled garden" environments,
including intranets, some providers' CDNs, extranets, 
and so on.

Frank A. Coluccio
DTI Consulting Inc.
212-587-8150 Office
347-526-6788 Mobile

On Sun Feb 18 10:54 , Andrew Lee  sent:


Hi Chris

Your statement makes something of a presumption as to the architecture
of a network.  In many networks, edge aggregation devices do not
participate in backbone routing, but simply pass the traffic they are
aggregating into the core.

One fairly well instrumented network that does have this edge/core
collapsed model is the Internet2 network.  You can find a lot of traffic
and other data for the network at:
http://noc.net.internet2.edu/i2network/live-network-status.html
You should be able to extract all the info you need from there.

/Andrew

Chris Develder wrote, On 2/18/07 5:46 AM:

Hi All,

In preparation of a course, I'm looking for reference material (paper,
report, talk...) giving real world data on the amount of transit traffic
(ie. not locally dropped or added, but passing through to other
(backbone) routers) in a "typical" edge router of a core network, esp.
ratio of local vs passthrough traffic (is it 30%, 40%...?) -- I don't
need absolute figures, just realistic estimates of that ratio.

Any help in locating such references would be highly appreciated.

Kind regards,
Chris




Current thread: