Re: MEDIA: ICANN rejects .xxx domain

[Martin Hannigan <hannigan () renesys com>]

At 02:22 AM 5/12/2006, Jim Popovitch wrote:

> Fred Baker wrote:
> > On May 11, 2006, at 8:42 PM, Jim Popovitch wrote:
> >
> > > Why not just plain ole hostnames like nanog, www.nanog, mail.nanog
> > For the same reason DNS was created in the first place. You will 
> > recall that we actually HAD a hostname file that we traded around...
>
> Let's not go backwards now.... ;-)
>
> Note: I didn't advocate replacing DNS with host files.  I'll attempt 
> to clarify:  If X number of DNS servers can server Y number of TLDs, 
> why can't X number of completely re-designed DNS servers handle just 
> root domain names without a TLD.
>
> Examples:
>
>     www.microsoft
>     smtp.microsoft
>     www.google
>     www.yahoo
>     mail.yahoo
>
> Why have a TLD when for most of the world:
>
>    www.cnn.CO.UK is forwarded to www.cnn.COM
>
>    www.microsoft.NET is forwarded to www.microsoft.COM
>
>    www.google.NET is forwarded to www.google.COM
>
>    etc., etc.
>
> There are very few arguments that I've heard for even having TLDs in 
> the first place.  The most common one was "Businesses will use .COM, 
> Networks will use .NET, Organizations and Garden Clubs will use 
> .ORG". When in reality Businesses scoop up all the TLDs in their name/interest.


Yes, but that was when you actually wouldn't dare get a .org for 
yourself unless
you really were qualified under the guidelines. Same for .net. The 
distinctions
have been meaningless for quite some time. They are simply placeholders.


> Why does it matter if your routers and switches are in DNS as 
> 123.company.NET vrs 123.routers.company
>
> I do understand that today's DNS system was designed with TLDs in 
> mind, and probably couldn't just switch over night.  But why can't a 
> next-gen system be put in place that puts www.microsoft and 
> www.google right where they go now whether you use .net, .com, .org, 
> or probably any other TLD?



Im having an offline discussion with a list member and I'll ask, why 
does it matter if
you have a domain name if a directory can hold everything you need to 
know about them
via key words and ip-addrs, NAT's and all?

-M<









--
Martin Hannigan                                (c) 617-388-2663
Renesys Corporation                            (w) 617-395-8574
Member of Technical Staff                      Network Operations
                                               hannigan () renesys com