nanog mailing list archives

Re: Anyone familiar with the SBC product lingo?


From: Jerry Pasker <info () n-connect net>
Date: Thu, 14 Apr 2005 17:09:47 -0500



(Anybody here *NOT* seen cases where the 2 fibers leave the building on opposite
sides, go down different streets - and rejoin 2 miles down the way because
there's only one convenient bridge/tunnel/etc over the river, or similar?)

Even if that's not the case, and it's still perfectly separated all the way to the CO, the CO is a common point of failure. Granted, the failure modes are very unlikely to occur for a CO, but they do exist. Those two separate paths of the ring have a way of always coming together somewhere, by design.

The only way to insure that doesn't happen is to have two sources of connectivity to a building, from two separate local carriers that have fiber going in two opposite directions (eg., one carrier to the east, one to the west), to two opposite area codes/LATAs that get transit from two different transit providers that have POPs in cities that are geographically the furthest apart (one to the north, one to the south, or east west, or whatever). As long as everything keeps heading in complete opposite directions, it becomes very assured that the common modes of failure diminish with distance.

This tactic works, and works well with IP using BGP, but it's something that would be beyond my scope of expertise to attempt to implement with anything else.

(someone mentioned earlier charging the 2 9's rate for providing 5 9's service...... it was a wake up call to myself.....I'm that guy!)

On a somewhat related, but kind of a little off topic note:

It always makes me chuckle inside to hear data centers tout their "dual grid connections" as a way to insure that the power "is hardly ever interrupted" Same basic principal. Sure they might be separate distribution feeders, and they might even come from separate distribution substations, and the subtransmission that feeds the distribution substations might even come from separate transmission substations... but within about a minimum of a 60-100 mile radius, it's nearly always connected together by the transmission grid.

Now, if there was a data center that had a power feed connection to say, ERCOT, the Eastern Interconnection, and the Western Interconnection.... THAT would be something to brag about.


Current thread: