nanog mailing list archives
Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs?
From: "Alexei Roudnev" <alex () relcom net>
Date: Mon, 26 Jan 2004 23:09:07 -0800
So what? Is is a sugnificant drawback? I do not think so. Both ISL and 802.1q require special interface cards (with extended frame size), and I do not see any reason, why 26 bytes vs 4 bytes makes big difference. /May be, the only pro for 802.1q tagging is it's possible implementation on the old interface cards, which did not allowed extra 30 bytes but allowed extra 4 bytes/. I am no saying that ISL is better tha 802.1q, but 802.1q is not much better than ISL, and (in some cases) is even worst. ----- Original Message ----- From: <sthaug () nethelp no> To: <alex () relcom net> Cc: <nanog () merit edu> Sent: Monday, January 26, 2004 9:10 AM Subject: Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs?
ISL _DOES NOT CHANGE_ packet size.An 802.1q tag adds 4 bytes to the Ethernet frame. ISL encapsulation adds 30 bytes to the Ethernet frame. Steinar Haug, Nethelp consulting, sthaug () nethelp no
Current thread:
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs?, (continued)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? ken emery (Jan 25)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? Alexei Roudnev (Jan 25)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? Brian Wallingford (Jan 25)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? Alexei Roudnev (Jan 25)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? Peter J Hill (Jan 26)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? Alexei Roudnev (Jan 26)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? sthaug (Jan 26)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? Scott McGrath (Jan 26)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? sthaug (Jan 26)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? Alexei Roudnev (Jan 26)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? Alexei Roudnev (Jan 26)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? haesu (Jan 27)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? Alexei Roudnev (Jan 25)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? ken emery (Jan 25)
- Re: Any 1U - 2U Ethernet switches that can handle 4K VLANs? sthaug (Jan 26)