nanog mailing list archives
Re: BGP Homing Question
From: Joe Abley <jabley () isc org>
Date: Fri, 27 Aug 2004 08:58:53 -0400
On 27 Aug 2004, at 08:13, Rick Lowery wrote:
If someone owns their own /20 which they received from Arin back in the day and they want to subnet and use part of it (/24) in Europe. Would their be any problems if the wanted to advertise the North American issued space from a European AS?
There should be no technical problem due to the origins of the numbers.There might be a problem with some operators filtering out the /24 if it's allocated from a block with consistent /20 allocation boundaries. However, if it's an old allocation this is not necessarily going to be the case (and many people are not that enthusiastic about allocation boundary filtering anyway).
If you poke around on www.arin.net you should find summaries by /8 for the longest allocation within each block. The paragraph above is only a concern if your specific /20 lives in a /8 where the longest allocation made by ARIN has a mask length less than 24 bits.
I know they would not be good Internet citizen, but if they needed to do this for a temp basis does anyone see an issue?
There's not much bad citizenry in what you are suggesting: the assigning-RIR problem is a non-problem, and your two sites are still only going to originate one prefix each (which they would presumably do even if you had a separate LIR assignment for the European node).
Joe
Current thread:
- BGP Homing Question Rick Lowery (Aug 27)
- Re: BGP Homing Question Joe Abley (Aug 27)
- Re: BGP Homing Question Patrick W Gilmore (Aug 27)
- Re: BGP Homing Question babylon (Aug 27)
- Re: BGP Homing Question Jared Mauch (Aug 27)
- Re: BGP Homing Question Randy Bush (Aug 30)
- Re: BGP Homing Question Joe Provo (Aug 30)
- Re: BGP Homing Question Daniel Roesen (Aug 30)
- Re: BGP Homing Question Patrick W Gilmore (Aug 27)
- Re: BGP Homing Question Joe Abley (Aug 27)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: BGP Homing Question babylon (Aug 27)
- RE: BGP Homing Question Michel Py (Aug 27)
- Re: BGP Homing Question Patrick W Gilmore (Aug 28)