Re: Ship seized for cutting Sri Lanka's internet link

[sgorman1 () gmu edu]

This all reminds me of an old Neal Stephenson quote from a piece he did for Wired back in the day.  There are more 
cables and a few more landing stations these days, but on the bottleneck side not much has changed

"In defense of telephony people, it must be pointed out that they are the ones who really know the score when it comes 
to sending bits across oceans. Netheads have heard so much puffery about the robust nature of the Internet and its 
amazing ability to route around obstacles that they frequently have a grossly inflated conception of how many routes 
packets can take between continents and how much bandwidth those routes can carry. As of this writing, I have learned 
that nearly the entire state of Minnesota was recently cut off from the Internet for 13 hours because it had only one 
primary connection to the global Net, and that link went down. If Minnesota, of all places, is so vulnerable, one can 
imagine how tenuous many international links must be. 

Douglas Barnes, an Oakland-based hacker and cypherpunk, looked into this issue a couple of years ago when, inspired by 
Bruce Sterling's Islands in the Net, he was doing background research on a project to set up a data haven in the 
Caribbean. "I found out that the idea of the Internet as a highly distributed, redundant global communications system 
is a myth,'' he discovered. "Virtually all communications between countries take place through a very small number of 
bottlenecks, and the available bandwidth simply isn't that great.'' And he cautions: "Even outfits like FLAG don't 
really grok the Internet. The undersized cables they are running reflect their myopic outlook.'' 

On Tue, 24 Aug 2004 13:53:37 BST, Carlos Friacas said:

> if yes, here we see once again the "benefits" of having a monopoly in the
> telecom industry. and a bad one it seems... even if the incumbent is the
> only way out of the island, it would seem wise (not cost-driven) to have a
> second cable at least connecting the island to the world... ;-)

And make sure the two landing stations are on opposite sides of the island.

But even then you can't win - I seem to recall that Sri Lanka has a small
problem with rebels - who could conceivably end up controlling one of
the stations.....