nanog mailing list archives
apathy (was Re: .ORG problems this evening)
From: Todd Vierling <tv () duh org>
Date: Fri, 19 Sep 2003 11:36:49 -0400 (EDT)
On Fri, 19 Sep 2003, Alex Bligh wrote: : > DNS site A goes down, but its BGP advertisements are still in effect. : > (Their firewall still appears to be up, but DNS requests fail.) Host : > site C cannot resolve ANYTHING from DNS site A, even though DNS site B is : > still up and running. But host site C cannot see DNS site B! : : What you seem to be missing is that the BGP advert goes away when the DNS : requests stop working. It didn't. That's the problem. I've repeatedly described how I do understand the methodology here. What's being expressed on this list is blind faith and trust in an anycast-only gTLD DNS scheme that has the possibility of routing to a single point of failure. This scheme has already failed once. ("When will it fail again?") Established gTLD practice has not put trust in an anycast routing scheme where one (1) destination might serve all queries for a host. What I've tried to express is that the years-established, standard DNS redundancy failover model could and should be implemented to complement -- not replace -- this anycast model for something as critical as a Big Three gTLD. That's fine; I give up due to pervasive community apathy. When this happens again, I'll be sure to bring up the archive URL to the head of this thread. <sigh> -- -- Todd Vierling <tv () duh org> <tv () pobox com>
Current thread:
- Re: .ORG problems this evening, (continued)
- Re: .ORG problems this evening E.B. Dreger (Sep 18)
- Re: .ORG problems this evening Todd Vierling (Sep 18)
- Re: .ORG problems this evening E.B. Dreger (Sep 18)
- Re: .ORG problems this evening Stephen J. Wilcox (Sep 18)
- Re: .ORG problems this evening bmanning (Sep 18)
- Re: .ORG problems this evening E.B. Dreger (Sep 18)
- Re: .ORG problems this evening bmanning (Sep 18)
- Re: .ORG problems this evening E.B. Dreger (Sep 18)
- Re: .ORG problems this evening just me (Sep 18)
- Re: .ORG problems this evening Alex Bligh (Sep 19)
- apathy (was Re: .ORG problems this evening) Todd Vierling (Sep 19)
- RE: apathy (was Re: .ORG problems this evening) Eric Germann (Sep 19)
- Re: apathy (was Re: .ORG problems this evening) Rodney Joffe (Sep 19)
- Re: apathy (was Re: .ORG problems this evening) Todd Vierling (Sep 19)
- Re: apathy (was Re: .ORG problems this evening) Richard A Steenbergen (Sep 19)
- Re: .ORG problems this evening E.B. Dreger (Sep 18)
- Re: .ORG problems this evening Majdi S. Abbas (Sep 18)
- Re: .ORG problems this evening Todd Vierling (Sep 18)