Re: Risk of Internet collapse grows

[David Diaz <techlist () smoton net>]

Well, it seems the national news medias picked up on this story.  How 
us "geniuses" re-engineered the internet into a few points that could 
be knocked out, killing the internet.  The explanation used a bad 
analogy to explain it to the public.

As already mentioned a lot of bad assumptions were made, and now we 
will be questioned based on those assumptions.

There has to be a better way for us to play devil's advocate without 
media feedback.

Happy Thanksgiving.

Dave

At 0:17 +0000 11/28/02, Stephen J. Wilcox wrote:
> On Wed, 27 Nov 2002, Sean Donelan wrote:
>
> >  On Wed, 27 Nov 2002 sgorman1 () gmu edu wrote:
> >  > The full paper is available at:
> >  >
> >  > http://whopper.sbs.ohio-state.edu/grads/tgrubesi/survive.pdf
> >  >
> >  > password: grubesic
> >  >
> >  > It was posted on the www.cybergeography.org website with the password,
> >  > plus I'm sure Tony would like the feedback.
> >
> >  Was this paper peer reviewed ?
> >
> >  I'm interested in the problem, but this is not the paper.
>
> Not -the- answer but a part of perhaps. I think the paper helps in 
> appreciation
> of the maths and processes behind the concept
>
> >  AT&T's network is the most vulnerable? While Onyx is among the least
> >  vulnerable?  Onyx is bankrupt, and their network is no longer in
> >  operation. I guess you could argue Onyx not vulnerable any more.  This
> >  paper starts out with some bad assumptions, such as there is one NAP in a
> >  city, one path between cities or the marketing maps in Boardwatch are
> >  meaningful.
>
> It does mention there being more than one NAP...
>
> Its also highlighting a point about increased resiliency through 
> mesh redundancy
> and it does acknowledge differences of scale.
>
> >  Until we figure out how to collect some meaningful starting data, we
> >  can't draw these types of conclusions.
>
> And therein lies the problem! Plenty of room for theorising tho!
>
> Steve

--

David Diaz
dave () smoton net [Email]
pagedave () smoton net [Pager]
www.smoton.net [Peering Site under development]
Smotons (Smart Photons) trump dumb photons