nanog mailing list archives
RE: ORBS (Re: Scanning)
From: Roeland Meyer <rmeyer () mhsc com>
Date: Sun, 27 May 2001 11:10:08 -0700
From: Derek Balling [mailto:dredd () megacity org] Sent: Sunday, May 27, 2001 10:49 AM At 9:11 AM -0700 5/27/01, Roeland Meyer wrote:A system that tests positive for ORBS , yet is using MAPS,will not be usedas a spam relay. Yet, ORBS will list such a system.I'm not sure I understand this logic: 1.) They test positive for orbs... so they ARE an open relay 2.) That system is using MAPS, which means that there is some subset of systems the open relay itself rejects mail from
I somehow missed your logic here. A MAPS blocked system is, by definition NOT an open-relay, since it IS MAPS-blocked. Yet, ORBS will list it as an open-relay. I agree, there is a disconnect here. Your second premis invalidates the first. This may be a semantic issue, please examine and clarify. A MAPS-blocked system may show as an open-relay to another system not listed in MAPS. However, it will show as closed to a system that is listed in MAPS. It all depends on the source of the test. AHA! Maybe ORBS should be listed in MAPS? That will certainly resolve this problem and ORBS will no longer show false positives.
Somehow that means that non-MAPS-listed sources (of which there are many) are somehow magically restricted from relaying through the open relay?
Since your first sylogy didn't parse, this one didn't either. I might point out that, since MAPS has been running for a few years, most if not all, the spammer sources are now listed.
Current thread:
- RE: Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning)), (continued)
- RE: Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning)) Vivien M. (May 29)
- Re: Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning)) Mitch Halmu (May 30)
- Re: Mitch tries to defend his open relay again (was Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning)) J.D. Falk (May 30)
- RE: ORBS (Re: Scanning) Derek Balling (May 27)
- RE: ORBS (Re: Scanning) Mitch Halmu (May 28)
- Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning) mike (May 29)
- RE: ORBS (Re: Scanning) John Fraizer (May 27)
- Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning) Steve Sobol (May 28)
- RE: ORBS (Re: Scanning) E.B. Dreger (May 27)
- RE: ORBS (Re: Scanning) Derek Balling (May 27)
- RE: ORBS (Re: Scanning) Patrick W. Gilmore (May 27)
- RE: ORBS (Re: Scanning) Derek Balling (May 27)
- Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning) Steve Sobol (May 27)
- Re: ORBS (Re: Scanning) E.B. Dreger (May 27)
- RE: ORBS (Re: Scanning) Patrick W. Gilmore (May 27)