nanog mailing list archives
RE: Statements against new.net?
From: "David R. Conrad" <david.conrad () nominum com>
Date: Tue, 13 Mar 2001 19:35:22 -0800
At 04:14 PM 3/13/2001 -0800, Mike Batchelor wrote:
> That one root must be supported by a set ^zone > of coordinated root servers administered by a unique naming > authority. Here is where I disagree.
...
I still say it's a self-serving statement with political motivations, and I hope I have adequately explained why I think that.
One could argue that "single naming authority" does not necessarily imply that a single body is making the decisions of what is or is not in the root zone. The use of a single body is (arguably) the _easiest_ solution to the root zone edit control problem, not necessarily the best solution. Clearly, a model in which multiple cooperative bodies manage the editing of the root zone is workable -- there are several empirical proofs of such. However, it can be argued that in such a model, the cooperative is the "unique naming authority".
The issue isn't really about this however. New.Net is not a part of a cooperative. They are a commercial company deciding on their own what is or is not a good top level domain -- they are asserting (with the help of @Home, Earthlink, mp3.com, etc.) that they are the unique naming authority. I, for one, do not believe that this is appropriate or desirable.
Rgds, -drc
Current thread:
- Re: Statements against new.net?, (continued)
- Message not available
- Re: Statements against new.net? Geoff Huston (Mar 13)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Vadim Antonov (Mar 14)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Patrick Greenwell (Mar 13)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Valdis . Kletnieks (Mar 13)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Scott Francis (Mar 13)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Havard Eidnes (Mar 13)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Valdis . Kletnieks (Mar 13)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Mike Batchelor (Mar 13)
- RE: Statements against new.net? David R. Conrad (Mar 13)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Mathias Koerber (Mar 13)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Clayton Fiske (Mar 14)
- RE: Statements against new.net? Mike Batchelor (Mar 14)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Clayton Fiske (Mar 14)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Eric A. Hall (Mar 14)
- Re: Statements against new.net? Valdis . Kletnieks (Mar 13)