nanog mailing list archives
Re: Napster and others...
From: "Scott McGrath" <s_mcgrath () bexair com>
Date: Tue, 07 Mar 2000 14:36:36 -0500
As a member of the dreaded 'Corporate America' and a end user I need to block it for now because of 1 excessive b/w usage. 2. "Mr J. Random Engineer did you knowingly allow a service to enter your premises which allowed my clients intellectual property to be infringed yes or no?" We need a system which allows "internet radio" for legitimate content and allows us to control bandwidth usage on end-user networks. The common carriers have an entirely different set of needs and to keep their common carrier exemption they cannot do anything about "excessive traffic" besides if your customers want more of your product (bandwidth) more power to them assuming of course that you have a method to charge for it! Shawn McMahon wrote:
At 09:48 AM 3/7/2000 -0500, you wrote:When you have limited bandwidth you need to ensure that it is used for what it is purchased for (email access to network based resources etc) and also as Napster moves MP3's you need to ensure that your facilities are not used for infringement on other's intellectualproperty so that you and your organization are not sued by rapacious lawyers unfortunate but there it is here is a short list in ACL format of Napster and other MP3 servers.It is not possible to do either, and by undertaking to do so you open yourself up to legal liabilities that otherwise wouldn't exist. On the other hand, if you block things that are consuming excessive bandwidth, you're in good shape.
Current thread:
- Re: Napster and others..., (continued)
- Re: Napster and others... Joshua Goodall (Mar 07)
- Re: Napster and others... Shawn McMahon (Mar 07)
- Re: Napster and others... Scott McGrath (Mar 07)
- "Bandwidth expands to fit the waste available" (Voidmstr's law) was: Re: Napster and others... Kai Schlichting (Mar 07)
- Re: Napster and others... Simon Lyall (Mar 07)
- Re: Napster and others... Scott McGrath (Mar 07)
- Re: Napster and others... Michael Ridley (Mar 07)
- Re: Napster and others... Scott McGrath (Mar 07)
- Re: Napster and others... John Kristoff (Mar 07)
- Re: Napster and others... Scott McGrath (Mar 07)
- Re: Napster and others... Shawn McMahon (Mar 07)
- Re: Napster and others... Scott McGrath (Mar 07)
- Re: Napster and others... Michael Ridley (Mar 07)
- RE: Napster and others... Christian Kuhtz (Mar 07)
- Re: Napster and others... Jeremy Porter (Mar 07)
- Re: Napster and others... Peter Galbavy (Mar 08)
- Re: Napster and others... Erik E. Fair (Mar 09)
- Re: Napster and others... Scott McGrath (Mar 09)
- Re: Napster and others... Michael Shields (Mar 09)