nanog mailing list archives

Re: Has PSI been assigned network 1?


From: "Michael F. Nittmann" <nittmann () wis com>
Date: Mon, 24 Apr 1995 08:32:20 -0500 (CDT)

Route holdowns:

los pobres paquetos: that's just the beauty and purpose of routing 
protocols to propagate the info so that los pobres paquetos don't clog 
the pipe with the goal of being dropped.

To hold routes eternally down is not good: what if the customer 
disconnects that network? I don't want to be notified by all leaf 
networks when they will hickup or disconnect for good. 

Mike

On Sun, 23 Apr 1995, Randy Bush 
wrote:

Don't know what other folk are seeing, or if y'all even look.  But a
significant number of leaf customer sites 'round these parts seem to be
pseudo-random route generators.  I watched a small POP, less than 100
customers, for about six weeks.  I would never had guessed that DEC, IBM,
MIT, and dozens of surprising Bs and Cs were in rural Southern Oregon.
I'm sure that the POP's peer ASs would have been very impressed if we had
redistributed those routes to external BGP sessions.

And we occasionally get some exciting announcements from overseas links.


To move along an other tangent...  What is the general wisdom on putting
pull-ups on route annoucements to deter route flap?  Vadim kindly gave me
a static Null 250 hack to keep announcement up even if the source of the
route drops it.  Hence, you won't get the !H until you get to our border.
Los pobre packitos will travel all the way and then get whacked.  Seems
to subvert one interpretation one could read into the intent of BGP.

randy


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Michael F. Nittmann                                             nittmann () wis com
Network Architect                                               nittmann () b3 com 
B3 Corporation, Marshfield, WI (CIX Member)               (715) 387 1700 xt. 158
US Cyber (SM), Washington DC                              (715) 573 2448
                                                          (715) 831 7922
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Current thread: