Interesting People mailing list archives
Technologist proposes Net neutrality solution
From: David Farber <dave () farber net>
Date: Thu, 30 Mar 2006 13:41:03 -0500
http://telephonyonline.com/regulatory/news/Net_Neutrality_Farber_032906/ Technologist proposes Net neutrality solution By Carol Wilson Mar 29, 2006 9:16 AM A former chief technologist for the Federal Communications Commission is calling for a fact-based solution to the Net neutrality issue, to bedetermined by a neutral group of experts, meeting out of the glare of the
current hype. David Farber’s credentials are considerable--as an academic, he didpioneering work in distributed computing and helped conceive and organize
early versions of the Internet including Computer Science Net (CSNet),NSFNet and NASA’s Research and Education Network (NREN). During 11 years at
Bell Labs, he helped design the first electronic switching system (ESS)--technology which became the heart of the modern phone network. Inaddition to a long academic career ending at the University of Pennsylvania
and the Wharton School of Business, he maintained a commercial businessdeveloping software, and served on many boards of directors for commercial companies, in addition to his post at the FCC. While in Washington, he led
the review of Time Warner’s acquisition of AOL, another in a series of issues where politics, business and technology collided. Farber said in an interview today that the current emotionally chargedarguments about Net neutrality are counter-productive and are not likely to
produce the solutions required to insure the Internet’s future.“We need to get a small set--15 people tops--to drill down and decide what
it is people agree to and what they don’t agree to,” he said. The group would be university-sponsored and include expert economists, regulatory officials and technologists. “It needs to be a fact-finding operation – that’s a first step.” Similar groups have been assembled to address issues such as spectrummanagement, Farber said. They enable work to be done quickly and quietly.
“We can get together under the auspices of CMU [Carnegie Mellon University,
where he is currently affiliated] and Penn and people can talk and say things they mean without attribution,” he said. “They can talk off therecord but to each other and not have to worry about being quoted endlessly
and out of context. It has to be fast and it has to inform the Congress with a set of facts. If in the process, one comes up with a resolution--happy day. If you don’t, you have the facts out.” Farber said it may be possible to “engineer the way out” of the current dilemma, which has pitted cable and telephone companies against Internet firms, ranging from Google and Yahoo! to the VoIP community and consumer groups, in a debate over whether providing “tiered” or premium-based services amounts to degrading all other Internet traffic. In a group of experts, potential solutions could be quickly vetted. “It’s one thing to mumble in public about that, it’s another thing to mumble among experts,” he said.Normally, such an issue could go before the National Research Council, he
said, but its approach would take more than a year to solve the problem, whereas his proposed approach would be much quicker. “We’re talking a month, not months,” Farber said. ------------------------------------- You are subscribed as lists-ip () insecure org To manage your subscription, go to http://v2.listbox.com/member/?listname=ip Archives at: http://www.interesting-people.org/archives/interesting-people/
Current thread:
- Technologist proposes Net neutrality solution David Farber (Mar 30)