Interesting People mailing list archives
IP: NAB - the Super Nova is imploding
From: David Farber <dave () farber net>
Date: Sun, 29 Apr 2001 16:31:53 -0400
To: OpenDTV Mail List <openDTV () topica com> From: Craig Birkmaier <craig () pcube com> Sender: <openDTV () topica com> NAB 2001 - The laws of physics still apply Throughout history we have seen examples of the role that technology can play in facilitating major shifts in power...those radical shifts that dislodge well entrenched interests allowing new "eras" of history to begin. One oft cited example is the invention of the printing press, which made it possible to break the stranglehold that the institutions of that time (principally the Catholic Church) held on the dissemination of information to the masses. Before the printing press, books were produced by hand, mostly by Monks - those who were privileged enough to own a book were among societies elite, but more important, they controlled knowledge and made certain that it conformed to the prevailing beliefs of the day... like the notion that the Earth was the center of the universe. In modern times we have witnessed major changes due to shift from an agricultural to manufacturing based economy; From horse drawn transportation to vehicles with "horsepower" to spare. And now we are seeing yet another sea change due to the ease with which we all can create, distribute and share information in the emerging digital world. Earlier this year at "Morning After" session at the ITS Technology Retreat, John Sprung created a mental picture of the current mess we are in with the transition to digital television broadcasting. John repainted the image we have all seen many times of Wiley E. Cayote, having run off the cliff, hanging in space, in suspended reality, just before the big fall. Sprung indicated that this is exactly where we "stand" today with the DTV transition. Well that was in February. As hard as it may be to believe, things have changed dramatically in just two months. The broadcasts business is no longer hanging in suspended animation...the bottom just fell out and Wiley and his ATSC standard have come crashing to earth. The irony of this is that it has absolutely NOTHING to do with technology. The bottom has fallen out of legacy broadcast business models worldwide. It matters not whether we are talking about ATSC or DVB-T, 8VSB, E-VSB, COFDM or ISDB-T. The fundamentals of the business are finally giving way to a new reality... TV Anywhere TV Anytime What You Want Is What You See The days of herding the masses round the TV set to drink the "kool-aid" from the government supported propaganda machines is finally coming to an end; in truth it has existed in suspended animation for nearly a decade. In the U.S. the broadcast establishment is fracturing from within. In Great Britain the grand experiment with DVB-T has hit the wall. The ITV/On Digital crowd has finally awakened to the reality that they are not competing with one another, but with the Death Star controlled by Rupert "Darth Vader" Murdoch and Newscorp. Everywhere one looks the reality is the same. Any business model based on trying to force people to sit down at a specific time to watch a program is withering. Meanwhile, business models based on accumulating targeted audiences over time are gaining momentum. In an era where we are constantly bombarded with messages that we don't want, people are willing to pay a premium for the content - AND THE ADS - that they do want. While I did not have time to attend the NAB keynote in person, I found the remarks of Eddie Fritts (which follow) to be quite revealing. Seems Mr. Fritts and company have finally discovered that broadcasting cannot defy the laws of the Universe forever, even with the help of their friends in Congress who have given them every possible competitive advantage. The "product life cycle" of NTSC has defied all logic. Somehow it has been possible to milk this business for more profits, even in the face of decline...a negative slope to the end of the product life cycle curve. But this time the bottom really has fallen out. Broadcasting has taken that final step off the digital cliff. The spin machine is busy trying to tell us that everything is OK now that that nasty modulation issue has been put behind us. But U.S. broadcasters know otherwise. There's a new atmosphere in Washington. It's deregulatory. We gave you what you asked for, and now we are going to watch as you feed upon one another. Regards Craig Birkmaier Pcube Labs Edward. O. Fritts National Association of Broadcasters NAB2001 All Industry Opening State of the Industry Address April 23, 2001 Good morning and welcome to NAB 2001. Let me tell you about three totally unrelated things that I've heard on the news recently, and then let me tell you what I think they mean to the NAB. Number one ... astronomers have made a discovery regarding supernovas. This discovery apparently could alter our very conception of the universe. Two the president of Russia has changed the lyrics to that country's national anthem. In place of the old Soviet lyrics about Lenin and communism's triumph, the new lyrics instead celebrate a "holy country ... protected by God." Quite a change. Three ...in February, E-toys announced that it was seeking bankruptcy protection. Its stock, which had once been as high as $86 a share, was down to nine cents a share when trading was stopped. Now, here's my point if scientists can alter something so basic as their conception of the universe, if Russians now sing of God rather than Lenin, if Internet high fliers can so quickly rise and crash to earth ... should we expect radio and TV broadcasting to be immune from such wrenching change? The answer, of course, is no. Broadcasting's universe IS changing. The real question is how we meet these challenges. On top of the technological, financial and political challenges broadcasters face, we now face the added challenge of division within our own ranks. Rather than focusing 100 percent on meeting the challenges from without, all of a sudden we are challenging ourselves from within. What I'm talking about, of course is the split between the affiliates and the networks. Never in our industry's history have tensions been so high. In the old Soviet national anthem that I just mentioned, they used to sing about, quote, "an unbreakable union of republics." The Russians removed that phrase in the new anthem. Some would suggest the concepts of union and unity have been removed from the NAB anthem. This is an unsettling time in any number of ways. There are those who worry about the future of our association and our industry. Well, I can tell you that I have total confidence in the future of the NAB. We will continue to be a vibrant, aggressive advocate for free broadcasting. We will remain strong, committed and effective ... with membership in all 50 states and in every congressional district in this nation! Over the last decade, we have an enviable record of public policy success. We've had victories in the Congress, the FCC, the courts and even in the Supreme Court. These victories don't count the scores of other actions harmful to free broadcasting that we've stopped, sidetracked or finessed. We haven't succeeded, however, just because OF OUR political expertise. We have been successful because free, local broadcasting is a public service and a public good. Neither this mission nor our credibility is about to disappear. Our members, who are integral parts of their communities, are not about to abandon their commitment to localism. What we're experiencing right now is nothing new. I don't want to minimize the hurdles before us, but we've had discord in our ranks before. There was a time, for instance, when radio was deeply divided, but they came back together for the common good. The NAB is still here doing what we need to do ... and we will continue to do so. And it's a darn good thing we ARE here ... Because our industry DOES confront some big challenges. Since we met a year ago we have a new President, a new Congress and a new FCC. While we generally expect to benefit from a lighter regulatory touch, some issues will be more difficult. Additionally, our economic playing field has been reversed in the last few months. For example, this industry is in the most difficult advertising market since the late '80s, early '90s. Added to that economic reality, we are up against more competitors than ever before -- satellite, cable, broadband, the Internet. All this is occurring at a time when we're faced with the very expensive transition to digital. The very future of broadcasting rests on the successful completion of this transition. Tennessee Williams said, "There is a time for departure even when there is no place to go." Now ... we all know where we must go -- to digital. The hard part is the logistics of bringing it about. This country faces a choice between two timelines. Either marketplace or governmental ... We can follow the marketplace timeline ... in which case the transition to digital will be elongated over many, many years. Or, we can follow a government deadline that forces consumers to replace nearly 300-million analog TV sets in just five years. I submit that if we follow the government timeline, there needs to be minimal government intervention to facilitate the needs of consumers. Today, for instance, if a consumer purchases a new digital TV set, takes it home, and plugs into cable, and turns it on, they will learn it doesn't pick up free, local broadcast channels. How does that benefit consumers? What's wrong with this picture? We contend there are three obstacles standing in the consumer's path to digital broadcasting. One, the cable gatekeepers must carry the local broadcast channels offering digital and HDTV programming. Two, TV manufacturers must put DTV tuners in every new set that is made. Consumers want and deserve sets that will receive both analog and digital. Three, the issue of DTV/ Cable interoperability must be resolved. It is not simple, but none of these issues are. Congressman John Dingell has said that the barriers to DTV transition may be "too great to overcome without additional government intervention." He is absolutely right. The transition to digital in this country has been handled about as effectively as California handled the deregulation of energy. WE are working to resolve these issues with the consumer electronics association. A sign of our partnership can be found at the DTV Store in the lobby of the Las Vegas Convention Center. On display there is a wide variety of DTV receivers available to consumers today. Most importantly, that display sends another important signal -- that broadcasters are committed to the DTV transition. On the other side of the aisle, Radio faces its own digital challenges but the signs look good for the iBiquity system providing in-band, on channel digital radio. We're excited about recent announcements from iBiquity denoting steady progress toward adoption of IBOC digital radio. Without a doubt, our biggest victory last year was in scaling back the FCC's Low-Power FM plan. This was a true victory for spectrum integrity. It was a tough fight. It took the entire year, but the NAB, the 50 State Associations and hundreds of local broadcasters protected the airwaves from increased interference. Battles such as this are why we exist as an organization. Unfortunately, all victories in Washington are temporary ... and nothing demonstrates that more clearly than the latest moves to reverse the LPFM legislation. Senator John McCain recently introduced a bill that would roll back the LPFM legislation of last year. So here we go again. Another challenge emanating from Washington is the so-called "campaign finance reform legislation. The truth is that it benefits the politicians but does nothing for the voting public. McCain Feingold is a clever means for politicians to buy even more air time for their negative ads. What's happening here is that the politicians have voted to give themselves the cheapest rates during the most valuable time slots. As Senator Don Nickles has said, "This is better than free time." They have granted themselves special privileges unavailable to the fast food restaurant or the auto dealership in the local marketplace. In the words of Chairman Billy Tauzin, "Why should a politician pay a lower rate than a Ford dealer?" The issues we face are indeed daunting. I call on broadcasters all across the country to redouble their efforts to meet these challenges. What we provide is a free, local service to the community. Broadcasters also provide over $8-billion a year in public service announcements and funds raised for local charities and disaster relief. What we provide is a public good, and that deserves defending. At the end of the day, our internal issues will be resolved, one way or another. Then what? Will the NAB remain an umbrella organization? You bet we will. Some say that this umbrella approach -- radio and TV, large and small, network and affiliate -- is our weakness. I believe it is our strength, a strength that has given us many victories over the years. And I publicly want to thank ABC for remaining with us. We value your standing side by side with us, in spite of your disagreement on the issue of the 35% ownership cap. We want to acknowledge your independence, your larger vision, your commitment to the long-term good of the broadcasting industry. Ladies and gentlemen, everything is still in place to continue our record of success. We never like to lose a member, large or small, but we are neither diminished nor demoralized. I can say with absolute confidence that we have the means and the members to continue the fight. We know who we are and we know where we're going. We are going onward. We are going upward. And we are going forward. Thank you very much. ==^================================================================ EASY UNSUBSCRIBE click here: http://topica.com/u/?bz8QYL.bAeipm Or send an email To: OpenDTV-unsubscribe () topica com This email was sent to: farber () cis upenn edu T O P I C A -- Learn More. Surf Less. Newsletters, Tips and Discussions on Topics You Choose. http://www.topica.com/partner/tag01 ==^================================================================
For archives see: http://www.interesting-people.org/
Current thread:
- IP: NAB - the Super Nova is imploding David Farber (Apr 29)