Interesting People mailing list archives
Elevator Music (not really)
From: David Farber <farber () central cis upenn edu>
Date: Thu, 23 Feb 1995 09:30:08 -0500
From: D.K.Kahaner, ATIP-Tokyo [kahaner () cs titech ac jp] Re: Elevator technology Date: 02/23/95 [MM/DD/YY] Dr. David K. Kahaner Asian Technology Information Program (ATIP) Harks Roppongi Building 1F 6-15-21 Roppongi Minato-ku, Tokyo 106 Tel: +81 3 5411-6670; Fax: +81 3 5412-7111 ATIP: A collaboration between US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) University of New Mexico (UNM) ------------------------------------------------------------------------ ABSTRACT. The Yokohama Landmark Tower, opened in 1993, has the worlds fastest elevators. The basic technologies required are described, as well as a comment about the marketing strategy the project illustrates. The following report is based on material in the Japanese publication JETRO, Jan 1995 pp2-5, describing the basic technology characteristics of the Landmark Tower elevator system (Yokohama), currently the world's fastest, built by Mitsubishi Electric Corporation. Following that, are some summary comments based on discussions with Western experts. The world's fastest passenger elevators in the Yokohama Landmark Tower building -- opened to the public on July 17, 1993 -- travel at speeds up to 750m/min providing a comfortable ride to the observation deck at the 69th floor in the 296 meter high-rise building from the 2nd floor in 40 seconds. Highly advanced new technologies were developed for the manufacture of these super-high speed elevators by the Inazawa Works of Mitsubishi Electric Corp. (MELCO), a world's leading manufacturer of elevators. The elevators in the Sunshine 60 Building in Tokyo, traveling at speeds up to 600m/min -- also delivered by Mitsubishi Electric in 1978 -- had to cede the world's high-speed record to the Landmark Tower elevators. The production of elevators is closely linked to the construction of high-rise buildings. As elevators are indispensable setups to high-rise buildings as means of vertical transportation, the demand for elevators has been expanding steadily, and is expected to grow further worldwide, although the building construction in Japan seems to have been progressing at a slower pace since the end of the bubble economy period. Construction of higher buildings and subterranean development in the urban areas are inevitable internationally. With the increase of gigantic buildings such as skyscrapers and subterranean constructions, high speed and super-high speed elevators will become more and more important in the future. In addition, there is a potentially big market due to the increasing need for installation of elevators in lower buildings and public facilities in view of the expanding ratio of aged people in the society. Elevator is a setup in which a steel cage is hoisted with ropes and moved vertically by the drive of the ropes with a traction machine. To keep up with the need for higher speed in concert with the construction of higher buildings, a series of diverse innovative technological developments have been achieved. Specifically, higher power motors for traction machines, electronic drive control equipment, energy saving mechanism in the overall system, higher performance safety devices, and the progress in the machining technologies of helical reduction gears for middle and low speed elevators. The most remarkable above all is the recent development of power electronics which has brought up the innovation in the drive control system for AC motors. The super-high speed elevators of Landmark Tower employ high-output AC traction motors with variable-voltage, variable-frequency (VVVF) drive control units which accurately control the running of elevator cars to achieve the world's fastest speed with good riding comforts, as well as energy saving. This report describes the outline of basic technologies, and the highly advanced technologies developed for the world's fastest elevators by the Inazawa Works of Mitsubishi Electric Corp. MECHANISM OF ELEVATOR The most commonly used rope-hoisted elevator consists of a cabin car cage, a traction machine with a drive control unit, and the hoistway in which the car travels up and down. The cage is connected to counter weights with ropes, and the ropes are driven by the traction machine via the rope sheave, in which ropes role in and out. The car moves upward and downward along the guide rails installed in the hoistway shaft. Guide rollers absorb the vibration generated by the friction between the cage and the rails. The counterweights are stacks of 30 to 50kg weight units made of cast iron or concrete in steel frames. Rails are with a T-shape cross section similar to rollingstock rails. Up to ten wire ropes possessing adequate strength are used to withstand the load of a cage. When the speed of the elevator exceeds the prescribed speed by 1.2-1.4 times, the overspeed governor clamps the governor rope. As the car continues to fall, the governor rope moves the fixed operating lever to raise the safety brake shoes of safety gear installed under the car to grip the guide rail. Friction between the brake shoes and the guide rails slows the car to a halt. At the bottom of the hoistway, damper device is installed as a precaution against the failure of the car's landing at the right position. TRACTION AND CONTROL SYSTEM Until the first half of 1980s, most of the high speed elevators employed the Ward Leonard System in which a set of motor and generator (MG set) is used for converting AC current into DC current. The DC current is supplied to the DC motors, which is the driving source of the traction machines in this system (see Fig. 2). With this system, the DC current generator is revolved at a fixed rate by an AC motor and the output voltage is controlled by altering the magnetic field voltage of the generator. The electric current with the controlled voltage is fed to the DC motors to achieve the control of the speed of the motors. As this mechanism allows easy control of the speed of traction machine motor, the Ward Leonard System had been used widely for high speed elevators for a long time. For example, the elevators in the Sunshine 60, which had been the world's fastest until the Landmark Tower elevators broke the record in 1993, are using this Ward Leonard System. Elevators are used intermittently but have to be kept always ready for use so that they can start moving promptly when passengers press the call buttons. This means, with Ward Leonard System elevators, the MG set has to be always kept running -- although energy has to be consumed while waiting for the use -- to avoid the long lead time before the elevators start moving if the MG set is started upon request. Thyristor Leonard System employs thyristor circuit which uses power transistors to convert the AC current into DC current for the DC traction machine motor. The response of the thyristor circuit is so quick that it can be started only when calls for use come. Energy consumption can be reduced by about 30% through the application of this system. Further progress in the power electronics has led to the development of VVVF inverters, which has enabled a wider use of AC motors as the driving source of traction machines. The control of AC motors is very difficult compared to DC motors, particularly at the higher revolution range. This fact had been preventing the wider use of AC motors despite their higher power and easier maintenance. The VVVF inverter system allows AC motors to be controlled with an accuracy equivalent to that for DC motors. Now, the AC motor based system is regarded as the one that will become the main system in the future as a result of the development of higher performance VVVF inverter which can be used for AC motors even for high speed and super-high speed elevators. HIGH SPEED ELEVATORS AND HIGH-RISE BUILDINGS Higher speeds of elevators have been pursued in concert with the progress of the construction of higher buildings. With elevators, high speed means faster than 120m/min and super-high speed faster than 360 m/min. Low speed is the range slower than 45m/min, and middle speed is the range from 60 to 105m/min. Superhigh-rise buildings, called skyscrapers, were first built in New York in the U.S. Empire State Building, with a height of 378m, was built in 1931 and 360m/min elevators were installed. Higher building had not been built for a long time until the World Trade Center Building -- with a height of 480m and 480m/min elevators -- was built in 1972. In 1973, the Chicago Sears Tower Building was completed with 442m height and 540m/min elevators. The first high-rise building in Japan was the Mitsui Kasumigaseki Building which was built in Tokyo in 1968. The Kasumigaseki Building has a height of 147m and 300m/min elevators were installed. Several tall buildings followed, and the Sunshine Building was built in 1977 with a height of 240m and 600m/min elevators. Recently, the New Tokyo Municipal Government Building was completed in 1993, to which VVVF system 540m/min elevators were installed. The 750m/min Landmark Tower elevators followed in July 1993. HELICAL GEARS The development of helical gears is a remarkable achievement in the field of elevator technologies. With middle and low speed elevators, gears have to be employed to reduce the revolution of motors before supplying to the rope sheave. Gears are very important component for lower speed elevators, while traction machines for super-high speed elevators are with a gearless structure. Worm gears and helical gears are known as the reduction gears. Although the helical gears' power transmission efficiency is higher than that of worm gears by more than 30%, worm gears have been more widely used due to the difficulty of machining of helical gears. Unless machining of gears is made with high precision, noises and vibrations occur. The recent progress in gear cutting machine and advance of machining techniques have made the use of helical gears practical, and now the elevators using the helical gears can be operated with 15% reduction of energy consumption compared to elevators using worm gears. MARKET FOR ELEVATORS Annual demands for elevators are estimated to be about 30,000 units in Japan, 20,000 in the U.S., 50,000 in Europe, and 12,000 in Southeast Asia, making the total worldwide market size about 140,000 units a year. Japan's demand of 30,000 a year is very large and the total number of currently operating elevators in Japan as of the end of March 1993 is reported to be about 380,000 units. THE WORLD'S FASTEST ELEVATORS The Yokohama Landmark Tower, with a height of 296m, is the tallest building in Japan. The building consists of a 70-story tower building and an adjacent 5-level shopping mall complex with a hotel banquet hall, etc. The high-rise tower contains 42 office floors up to the 48th floor and 18 hotel floors on the 52nd floor and above, 3-level sky restaurant, observation deck and sky lounge/banquet hall. There are 52 elevators and 8 escalators for vertical transportation in the tower complex, 28 elevators and 56 escalators -- including 2 spiral escalators -- in the adjacent building. The 3 units out of the 52 elevators in the tower complex are the world's fastest passenger elevators, which travel at 750m/min. The outline of the highly advanced technologies which have made these fastest elevators possible are described below. TRACTION MACHINE AND DRIVE CONTROL SYSTEM * Traction machine The newly developed traction machine -- which provides the required traction drive for the super-high speed and heavy hoisting load for the long hoistway traveling -- employs an eight-pole AC motor with large power capacity of 120kW, and has a gearless drive mechanism. 10 suspension ropes, each 18mm in diameter, and a large sheave, 980mm in diameter, are used to support the large load. The rigidity of the motor was reinforced and the optimum numbers of slots of rotor and stator were selected to reduce the magnetic noise generated by the large AC motor. The traction machines for the Yokohama Landmark Tower are the largest ever used by Mitsubishi Electric in output capacity and weight-output: 120kW, weight: 12.5 ton. * Drive control system To supply the large electric current with optimum voltage and frequency to the motor, inverter/converter circuit with variable-voltage, variable-frequency (VVVF) system is employed. Six 300A transistor modules are connected in parallel for the converters/inverters. The input current and output currents are controlled by pulse width modulation (PWM). A high-performance digital signal processor is mounted for the control of the circuit. To realize good riding comfort in the high-speed elevator, it is important to reduce the vibrations which are substantially increased as the speed increases. Torque ripple generated in the motor is one of the causes of the vibrations, particularly the vertical vibration of the elevator cars. Therefore, several advanced circuit control mechanisms -- such as a function to compensate the voltage disturbance caused by the inverter's dead time function, etc. -- are used to reduce the torque ripple. * Safety devices Safe gear The safety gear, an emergency braking system installed under the car, is equipped with safety brake shoes which gap the guide rail when a higher-than-rated speed is detected, to slow the car to a halt by friction between the brake shoes and the guide rail. With the 750m/min elevator, the brake shoes have to cope with large kinetic energy, about twice as large as that for 600m/min elevator. Conventional shoes made of cast iron or alloys would wear out when the shoes' operating speed reaches 800m/min due to the temperature elevation on the shoes' rubbing surfaces, resulting in insufficient braking performance. However, the safety device for the 750m/min elevator is required to deal with the maximum speed of 937m/min. Therefore, it was necessary to develop new ceramic shoes which can withstand the high temperature to assure the desired reliable braking performance. Oil buffer The oil buffer absorbs the shock and decelerates the speed of the elevator car at the bottom of the elevator shaft in case the car fails to stop at the bottom floor. The developed oil buffer, the largest ever produced for elevators, has a stroke of 4,000mm and a spring made of high-tensile steel is installed at the end of the stroke that receives the plunger flange. Cabin cage Riding comfort of elevator is particularly affected by lateral vibration and aerodynamic noise. Lateral vibration, mainly caused by curvatures of the guide rails, increases in proportion to speed. The degree of lateral vibration varies, depending upon the degree of forced displacement, frequency of the displacement and the vibration characteristics of the car. The reduction of car vibration is vitally important to achieve a comfortable ride with super high-speed elevators. It was possible to reduce the vibration by 20% through the reduction of the curving degree of the guide rails, and through the improvement in the vibration characteristics of the car-by using a roller-guide with newly developed oil-filled dampers that reduce lateral movement, and placing additional dampers between the car frame and cabin. Elevators are also subject to aerodynamic noise which is caused by the airflow around the traveling car. With high speed elevators, the aerodynamic noise becomes a more serious problem than the mechanical noise caused by the contact between an elevator and the guide rails because the aerodynamic noise becomes larger in proportion to the wind velocity to the (approximately) sixth power -- aerodynamic noise is usually louder than the mechanical noise at 750m/min. Therefore, it is very important to reduce the aerodynamic noise. Streamlined covers, designed according to the results from experimental analysis, were mounted at the top and bottom faces of the car. Aerodynamic noise is likely to enter the car through door due to the clearance between the doors and the cabin for the door open/close structure. As a solution, sound insulation shields were applied to seal the clearance when the doors were closed. A double-wall structure, separating the inner walls from outer, is also employed to reduce the noise caused by the vibration of car walls due to air pressure fluctuation. Also, to suppress the reverberation of the noise which enters the car, a double-floor structure of punching metal and an air gap underneath -- with a carpet made of sound-absorbing porous material placed on top -- was developed. SIMULATION Integrated simulation tools of computer software, including a finite-element method (FEM), as well as testing equipment/devices, were indispensable for the development of the 750m/min elevators. For example, such a super-high speed elevator requires testing of acceleration and deceleration in the hoistway as long as 200m or over, far longer than the hoistway of the testing tower. Therefore, simulations on computer were made and many tests were carried out through the specially developed traction drive control simulators on the ground to verify and analyze the results gained from the computer simulations, obtaining more information on the dynamic characteristics. A traction motor was connected to a load-supplying motor via a flywheel, and the actual control panel was installed to supply voltages and currents according to the designated speeds for acceleration and deceleration, or running at fixed speeds. The load-supplying motor supplies the equivalent torques for motoring and regenerative braking according to the loads demanded by the car. In this way, testings were conducted under almost the same conditions as the actual runs. The three-dimensional finite element method (FEM) program "ANSYS" was used to analyze the temperature characteristics of the shoes' rubbing surface, and the result indicated that the temperature on the rubbing surface would be elevated to a temperature higher than 750'C at 900m/min. "Shoe material selection test" was conducted with a disk test device, in which the shoe was activated at the predetermined speed by the rotation of the disk. Then, a free-fall test was made using a 1/10-scale model car to confirm the accuracy and consistency of data gained from computer simulations. After the two tests, the braking performance of the safety device was confirmed by a test made in the test tower of the Inazawa Works under conditions equivalent to the actual elevator setup. For the design of the oil buffer, dynamic characteristics of elevator car were analyzed in the deceleration simulation taking the actual speed and load into consideration in order to achieve the desired buffer functions. Also, for researching ways to improve car vibration characteristics, the model characteristics were simulated by a FEM program followed by simulations using a vibration test device. INAZAWA WORKS AND MANUFACTURE OF ELEVATORS Mitsubishi Electric Corp. started the production of elevators and escalators in 1931, and the Inazawa Works was established in 1964 as a specialized production facility for the manufacture of elevators/escalators. The works is the world's largest factory in this field with a labor force of 1,470, a land area of 184,000m^2 and a floor area of 93,400m^2. The flow of manufacturing process up to shipment in the factory is controlled dividing components into the following 5 blocks taking the convenience for the installation at customer sites into consideration, as the production process of elevators completes when they are installed in the buildings. Block(A) Cabin entrance components (destination button, entrance unit, threshold, door, etc.) Block(B) Power/control components (control panel, traction machine, frames for traction machine fitting, rope shackle beam, overspeed governor, etc.) Block(C) Hoist room components (guiderail, buffer, buffer base, etc.) Block(D) Cabin structural components (cage frame, cage floor, safety gear, brake shoes, suspension rope, counterweight, tension sheave, etc.) Block(E) Cabin components (cabin body panel, cabin door, door control unit, etc.) Elevators are manufactured with diverse specifications for individual orders with a system in which the manufacture, delivery and installation of each block of components are made in concert with the timing required by the progress of building construction work. Maintenance technical service after the installation is also an integral part of the total system, for which Mitsubishi Electric provides a network of more than 220 service centers throughout Japan. The topic making achievements by Mitsubishi Electric in the elevator manufacture field are described here to illustrate the development of elevator production technology. 1935-First elevators and escalators delivered. 1966-Total number of elevators and escalators manufactured passes the 10,000 mark. 1970-Superhigh-speed elevator (300m/min) developed. 1972-New group-control system elevator, the OS System 700, marketed. Superhigh-speed elevator (450m/min) developed. 1974-Total number of elevators and escalators manufactured passes the 50,000 mark. 1978-World's fastest passenger elevators (600m/min) delivered. 1982-inclined elevator marketed. Japan's first VVVF inverter controlled elevator marketed. 1983-Total number of elevators and escalators manufactured passes the 100,000 mark. 1988-World's first zig zag elevators delivered. 1989-Total number of elevators and escalators manufactured passes the 150,000 mark (including 30,000 units for overseas). 1990-Delivered elevators for use in a skyscraper owned by the Bank of China in Hong Kong (the tallest building in Asia, 368 meters). 1993-Delivered the world's fastest passenger elevator (750m/min) Total number of elevators and escalators manufactured passes the 200,000 mark (including 39,000 units for overseas). *Inazawa Works, Mitsubishi Electric Corporation 1, Hishimachi, Inazawa City, Aichi Pref. 492 JAPAN Tel:+81-587-23-1111; Fax: +81-587-24-5674 ------------------------ COMMENT: Most elevator companies are aware of the MELCO Landmark Tower elevator and related technical developments. It illustrates several key points about the construction industry and related building systems markets in Japan. 1. In the construction industry in Japan, it is common that member companies of the same keiretsu work together on large or showcase projects. The Landmark Tower is a showcase for Mitsubishi Estate and Mitsubishi Electric. This coupling between developers and building systems makers of the same keiretsu is common particularly for such large projects. For example, a close working relationship exists between Sumitomo Realty and NEC, who are both members of the Sumitomo Group. NEC manufactures building systems such as HVAC controllers, building management systems, security systems, etc. 2. The high speed elevator in Yokohama also illustrates the single attribute development strategy of elevator makers in Japan. In this case, MELCO selected speed as the primary attribute to develop for this project. Although many other technologies had to be improved, such as safety devices, the thrust of the development effort was on improving cab speed. The Landmark Tower elevator is clearly the fastest elevator in the world. The top speed of the elevator is not confirmed yet. Latest figures in the technical literature indicate a top speed of 800m/min. 3. The Landmark Tower elevator was developed and installed to fulfill a need and also as a showcase project. Customer demand for elevators that travel at speeds of 750m/min is not large, but MELCO created a distinct marketing advantage by developing the fastest elevators in the world. This approach is particularly effective in the construction industry of Japan, which is hierarchical, and where owner-vendor interactions are limited. In addition, having a product that certifiably excels in a noteworthy characteristic is highly desired by Japanese customers. --------------------------END OF REPORT---------------------------
Current thread:
- Elevator Music (not really) David Farber (Feb 23)