Re: NetBIOS info

[billp () ROCKETCASH COM (Bill Pennington)]

Great stuff. Thanks Robert! A few comments... Maybe more along the line
of a rant but...

It just seems a little silly to me that in order to prevent this stuff
from landing on my link I need to setup PTR records for all my boxes.
What if I do not want PTR records (for whatever sick and twisted reason)
now I have to put up with all this cruft getting shoved down my pipe.

I think we can agree that not everyone is going to have PTR records
setup or even configured correctly to stop this stuff. It looks like a
big bandwidth hog to me. If gethostbyaddr fails then let it fail no need
to send out more packets. Also someone sent me an e-mail wondering if
you could use this as an attack method. It would seem like an easy way
to guess the OS without ever sending a probe packet to the host. If you
had some Netbios bomb or auto windows hack tool you could setup a site,
wait to get some Netbios request then attack. I am sure there is a
better way to handle it but that is a topic for Vuln-dev not here.

Ok of the soapbox... :-)

Robert Graham wrote:
> I've added a couple of pages worth of text to my firewall forensics
> document
> in order to discuss the NetBIOS stuff.
> http://www.robertgraham.com/pubs/firewall-seen.html#netbios
>
> Some recent questions on this list that I've tried to address in the
> above
> document are:
>
> Q: I've seen a lot more lately.
> A: Over the past year, Windows products that do reverse lookups have
> become
> more popular. Also, you may have misconfigured your DNS.
>
> Q: What is the exact specifics of the packets (length, etc.)?
> A: I've put a complete packet dump into the doc.
>
> Q: But my site doesn't run any form of NetBIOS or Windows...
> A: ...but it has IP addresses, which is all the Windows clients care
> about.
> In any event, it's not a TCP/IP thing, it's a Windows thing.
>
> Q: ...Internet Explorer...
> A: I believe that Internet Explorer doesn't do reverse queries; it's
> something else.
>
> Q: ...bandwidth...
> A: Actually, less than the DNS queries that usually precede the
> NetBIOS
> queries.
>
> In any event, if you are seeing a lot of these queries, you should
> immediately suspect your DNS servers. Windoze only sends the NetBIOS
> packet
> if the DNS fails. In other words, the "cause" of a lot of NetBIOS
> traffic is
> faulty DNS. See the section:
> http://www.robertgraham.com/pubs/firewall-seen.html#10.6
>
> Robert Graham

--

Bill Pennington