Re: Honeyd ping problem

[Javier Fernandez-Sanguino <jfernandez () germinus com>]

Sorry for answering to this so late but I actually had the same 
problem yesterday.

brian.g.plourde () us pwc com wrote:

> I was hoping someone could help me with a honeyd ping problem that I am 
> having.  My honeyd.conf file is extremely simple, a couple of addresses 
> bound to a windows template.  I run arpd, then honeyd with a -df switch 
> pointing to the same segment of my 172 network that arpd is pointing to.
>
> The problem is that honeyd is replying to ALL addresses within my 
> designated range-- even when they are not bound to hosts in my conf file. 
> For example, I can ping 172.x.x.25 (bound to windows) and 172.x.x.30 (not 
> bound) and I receive the same reply-- even with a traceroute.

That's actually expected, but it's not evident. Honeyd will take over 
all the network addresses you define in the command line, no more no 
less. It will not answer to IP addresses if not given in the CLI even 
if the are bound in configuration templates and it will answer to IP 
addresses given in the CLI even if they are _not_ defined in 
configuration templates.

So if you do

# honeyd (...) 172.16.0.0/24

And honeyd's honeyd.conf only holds templates for 172.16.0.1 and 
172.16.0.2, honeyd will actually answer back ICMP requests for all of 
the addresses in the range, but will only allow port connections to 
the addresses which do have a template. That's why, if you run 'nmap 
-sP', all of the hosts will appear to be up and running.

Similarly, if you have in your configuration file template definitions 
for hosts in a 10.0.0.0/16 and 172.16.0.1 (which is a router to the 
subnet) and you run honeyd as:

# honeyd (...) 172.16.0.1

Honeyd will only "claim" that IP address and you will not be able to 
get to the 10 network. You need to run honeyd with:

# honeyd (...) 172.16.0.1 10.0.0.0/16

For the above configuration (multiple networks through routers) to work.

That's actually not self-evident from the configuration files, 
documentation available or the manpage (I'm going to report an 
ammendment to it). Probably most people are running honeyd without 
specifying an IP address/network, which would work in any case (since 
then it would claim _all_ IP addresses it see).

Regards

Javier