Re: Reuters: Microsoft to give holes info to Uncle Sam first - responsible vendor notification may not be a good idea any more...

[Devdas Bhagat <devdas () dvb homelinux org>]

On 12/03/05 11:15 -0600, J.A. Terranson wrote:
> This "story" really just reflects what has been going on in the real world
> for some time now.
>
> Microsoft, Cisco, Juniper, etc., all have both vested interests and public
> policy interests in notifying those who would be most affected first.

Which public? Are you a member of the public? Am I?

> This is good public policy as well: if the national infrastructure is
> compromised, we are all up shit's creek, if Joe's Corner Store is

Which nation? From my PoV, it is the general user who needs to be
informed first. A whole bunch of us have more problems with Windows
holes even though we do not use Windows, simply because of the traffic
volume generated.
Perhaps you would have liked the slamer or blaster patches released to
the US government first, and only then to the general public?

> compromised, only Joe and possibly Joe's small geographic user base is
> hosed.

Unless there are a very large number of Joe's affected.

> Decrying this shows you have not thought the problem through Tamas.

I can support Cisco not publicly announcing a hole until the network
backbone is upgraded (I don't have to like it, but I will support it
because it makes sense to protect critical infrastructure from a DoS
attack first.) [1].

I can not support Microsoft doing the same thing, because the problem is
at the edge of the network, and it affects _others_ who should not be
affected by it. 

Devdas Bhagat

[1] If it was a mere DoS, sure, notify your larger customers first. 
If it is not a DoS, but an exploit which allows for outsider control,
then selective notification is irresponsible.
(The Cisco statement is wrt the recent DoS stuff when Cisco
notified the backbone operators before the offical advisory).
_______________________________________________
Full-Disclosure - We believe in it.
Charter: http://lists.grok.org.uk/full-disclosure-charter.html
Hosted and sponsored by Secunia - http://www.secunia.com/