RE: Skip the PDM

["Crissup, John (MBNP is)" <John.Crissup () us millwardbrown com>]

  I agree with your thoughts about the PDM.  You are correct, in that the
PDM simply converts the various settings to character based commands and
enters them into the PIX.  In fact, you can even review the command lines
before you apply them.

  As for myself, I played with the PDM for about three days when I first
installed our two model 520 PIXes.  I quickly abandoned that idea for the
command line instead.  Of course, I'm an old DOS guy who really can't stand
graphical interfaces anyway.  I've always believed graphical interfaces are
for monkeys who want to claim to be admins without having to learn how to
actually administer the device.  ;-)

--
John



-----Original Message-----
From: Robert Fenerty [mailto:robert () fenerty com]
Sent: Wednesday, November 19, 2003 6:42 PM
To: firewall-wizards () honor icsalabs com
Subject: [fw-wiz] Skip the PDM


Hi,

Although I sense that many subscribers to this list are the of the
ipchains/linux ilk, I thought I'd tell you about my experience
configuring a  PIX 501 at a client's site.  A pretty standard setup,
which took me THREE AND A HALF HOURS to install.  I think we can all
agree that I'm not a firewall wizard.  Maybe an apprentice to the guy
who mixes the mortar for the firewall.

The PIX Device Manager (PDM) is a GUI-based app that runs as a web
server on the PIX 501.  The 501's a tiny SOHO box with a Command-Line
Interface (CLI) fairly similar to those found on Cisco routers.  The
differences tripped me up a bit; like grep options on HP-UX if you were
raised on Sun.

So to "speed things up" I tried using the PDM.  Bad idea.  In my network
design, the office network uses the 172.16.x.y network to avoid any
routing problems that might arise when remote workers with 192.168.x.y
home networks connect to the office via software VPN.

So I tell the GUI that the "inside" interface is 172.16.1.1, and the
DHCP pool starts at .2.  Specify the gateway, DNS, etc. and you're done.
Right?  Wrong.  I'm guessing that the PDM just collects command lines
and sends them to the PIX.

The first error pops up when "ip address inside 172.16.1.1 255.255.0.0"
conflicts with the factory default DHCP pool, which starts at
192.168.1.2.  So the interface IP isn't changed.  And the request to
change the DHCP pool doesn't match the still-unchanged factory IP
address, so that's ignored too. At least the PDM pops up error messages,
and it was pretty obvious to me what was going on.  So I fixed it
manually.

But the client paid $500 for this box.  And a $100 Linksys or SMC box
wouldn't have had this problem.  You'd think Cisco could do better.

Then the DHCP server on the PIX wouldn't vend IP addresses.  No sniffer
handy, so I tried various debug options on the PIX.  Finally got an
error message from the DHCPD saying that DHCP wasn't enabled.  This was
odd, considering that "dhcp enable inside" and other dhcp settings were
in place.  I don't know what I did to kick start it, but it eventually
started lending everyone IP addresses from its stingy pool of 32 DHCP
leases.  It was pretty easy to setup the rest of it.

Anyway, the point of this message was to say that the PDM is a rotten
little piece of software that only confuses things.  So skip the PDM.

Robert Fenerty


_______________________________________________
firewall-wizards mailing list
firewall-wizards () honor icsalabs com
http://honor.icsalabs.com/mailman/listinfo/firewall-wizards
_____________________________________________________
This email is confidential and intended solely for the use of
the individual or organization to whom it is addressed. Any
opinions or advice presented are solely those of the author
and do not necessarily represent those of the Millward Brown
Group of Companies.  DO NOT copy, modify, distribute or
take any action in reliance on this email if you are not the
intended recipient.  If you have received this email in error
please notify the sender and delete this email from your system.
Although this email has been checked for viruses and other
defects, no responsibility can be accepted for any loss or
damage arising from its receipt or use.
______________________________________________________

_______________________________________________
firewall-wizards mailing list
firewall-wizards () honor icsalabs com
http://honor.icsalabs.com/mailman/listinfo/firewall-wizards