Re: [Full-disclosure] Standing Up Against German Laws - Project HayNeedle

[Duncan Simpson <dps () simpson demon co uk>]

I know this is obvious to everyone on bugtraq, but nobody seems to that told 
P.S.Ziegler yet. (He might or might not be aware of these facts).

If the report is right and logs recoriding you connecting and obtaining an IP 
address are a concern then you should be terrified already. I suspect that I 
could reconstruct much of what you did online given access to all the 
asssociated logs. Getting an IP address from a DHCP server and using almost 
any other service whatsoever usually generates at least an IP address and 
timestamp. Bind 9 has logs, and they are on by default, so big brother might 
be able to deduce a lot just using your ISP's DNS logs.

When I say that I got this spam from IP address X at time Y, and give full 
headers to back this up, most ISPs work out who was responsible and nuke their 
account. I do not think the "a virus sent that spam not me" or "nobody told me 
not to send spam" line is very effective. If you allowed a virus to send spam 
then the internet does not need your box. Period.

The signal-to-noise logic probably does work, but I am not sure the legal 
angle does. If you were *deliberately* ran the software that acidently 
downloaded that kiddie porn the suggested angle might not work.

A law requiring log data to be retained for 6 momths should be a major problem 
to enforce. Last time I think the UK mooted this it did not happen 
(disclaimer: this might have been a trial balloon designed to generate flak). 
My reaction at the ISP end was "OK, will you buy us the extra hardware 
required?" with the intention the answer would be "no" and the plan quietly 
killed. (Thinking that plain daft things will not be enacted is not always 
reliable, unfortunately).

Of course the "hand over your keys" law is a lot less effective tbat the 
government thinks. If an hour has passed they can have my host private key 
then I no longer have one of the keys required.

-- 
Duncan (-:
"software industry, the: unique industry where selling substandard goods is
legal and you can charge extra for fixing the problems."