Snort mailing list archives
Re: List
From: Joe McAlerney <joey () SiliconDefense com>
Date: Wed, 13 Mar 2002 17:01:32 -0800
Mike Poor wrote:
I am aware of the work that Silicon Defense has undertaken with regards to Snort, and was surprised when M. Steeles tone seemed more like a sales rep then someone trying to help out a fellow snorter. I think that the folks over at snort.org have done a good job (still a learning process of course) at rearing the project and will continue to do so. I know that Marty has always been concerned with the portablity of Snort, and snort users should know that they can count on finding appropriate source files, binaries, packages, and documentation right here, on snort..org.
As you might imagine, that "tone" is being addressed (even more) in light of current events. *ugh..* The guys at Snort.org have done a tremendous amount of quality work for the public, and continue to do so. There is no doubt about that, and you won't find one person who agrees otherwise. Back when the world was bright, shiny and new we threw ideas around on the devel list and worked on ways to get our research into Snort for the community to use, why? Well because it's much more enjoyable to get a compliment from a user than a dollar from a customer. I'm sad to see things turn sour over miscommunication.
On Wednesday 13 March 2002 07:00 pm, Joe McAlerney enlightened us with: "The tricky part for us is to help people without it looking self serving. If Mike Steele points Windows user Bill to his documentation, it comes across far worse then if some other random person did. This is why we're trying to get the docs up on Snort.org, so we can link there. Mike gets these kinds of questions literally a dozen times a week, and most always it is answered "in the documentation". " he gets these requests dozens of times a week? I dont see a problem of him responding to people on your own list (if that is what you are referring to), and telling them to rtfm or whatever it is that he is replying... that is on your list, and your domain. Now, answering requests for help from the snort-users list with : go to our site, download our documentation, not that stuff from snort.org... would be similar to someone asking a question about snort and one of the sourcefire guys saying... try out one of our sensors... go to our site and view our screenshots ... dl a brochure, and by the way our product does bla bla bla.. there is no place for that on this list.
Yes he does. The guy can't get his work done, so he has to reply at home. That's dedication, and it's sad to see him put in such an awkward position. Mike S. is probably one of the most non-threatening guys I know, and an hour in the room with him would show anyone that. I agree for the most part with the second scenario you painted. If you mull through the e-mails, you'll see examples of us responding to these types of questions regardless of which installer they used (who cares right?). Mike's comment came across bad, because he was speaking with what he's familiar with. This should be obvious to everybody in retrospect. However, he's not sending people to a product. He's sending them straight to the documentation where no mention of our products exists. You certainly won't find any one of us mentioning our products on the list unless someone asks "What commercial products are available for Snort?". It doesn't really occur too often anyway. When this did occur, notice that we followed up another post by directing the poster to other vendors in competition with ourselves. That should be the nature of the list don't you agree? Personally, I would like it a snort-commercial list was created for things like that.
We all owe, Stewart and crew included, a big enormous thanks to Marty Roesch, regardless of how much work and effort we have or have not put into the Snort project.
We have and will continue doing this. This is sort of what I am interested in. What does it take to show appreciation? Should showing appreciation somehow nullify any concerns someone has?
Marty, thanks.
sqrt(ditto)
Mike Poor
-Joe M. -- Joe McAlerney Software Developer / Security Consultant joey () SiliconDefense com Silicon Defense: IDS Solutions -=- http://www.silicondefense.com/ _______________________________________________ Snort-users mailing list Snort-users () lists sourceforge net Go to this URL to change user options or unsubscribe: https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/snort-users Snort-users list archive: http://www.geocrawler.com/redir-sf.php3?list=snort-users
Current thread:
- List Mike Poor (Mar 13)
- Message not available
- Re: List Mike Poor (Mar 13)
- Message not available
- Message not available
- Message not available
- Re: List Joe McAlerney (Mar 13)
- Message not available
- Re: List J. Craig Woods (Mar 14)
- Re: List spyguy703 (Mar 14)
- <Possible follow-ups>
- Re: List Joe McAlerney (Mar 14)