RE: Is ipchains -y secure enough?

["Golden_Eternity" <bhodi () bigfoot com>]

Be sure that the system is set to assemble fragmented packets. I don't know
if ipchains in particular is vulnerable to that problem, but I have heard of
other cases where it was possible to fragment a packet so that the TCP flags
weren't interpreted by the firewall and allowed to pass through.

Also, before you use '! -y', be sure you understand what it does. Since -y
triggers on packets that contain a syn and not ack or fin, the opposite of
that is a packet that contains fin and ack but not syn.

iptables provides much more control over the flags that trigger a rule, but
its still fairly new so that may or may not be an option for you.

> -----Original Message-----
> From: Philip Stoev [mailto:philip () stoev org]
> Subject: Is ipchains -y secure enough?
>
> Excuse me for the ignorance, but I would like to ask if the community
> considers ipchains rules containing the -y flag as secure for
> the purpose of
> TCP filtering. Such a rule will prevent the stablishment of
> TCP connections
> to the host being firewalled. Is there a way to curcumvent such a
> protection?