nanog mailing list archives
Re: MSA’s and network architecture
From: Mark Tinka <mark@tinka.africa>
Date: Fri, 20 May 2022 10:27:08 +0200
On 5/18/22 11:30, Etienne-Victor Depasquale wrote:
Agreed - but wouldn't it be fair to say that, nonetheless, the availability of an MSAsupports the development of network architecture?
Of course, it would. After all, we want two sides to be able to speak to each other, to create this Internet :-).
With an MSA, there is some limited, common basis for a discussion in an ecosystem of vendors and network operators. That should support development of architecture.
It's nice and stable as a technology stabilizes. But when the next thing needs to be built (400Gbps today, 800Gbps tomorrow, maybe 1Tbps in 5 years or less), vendors like to compete on who can come up with the first (not the best) solution. Industry then catches up a while later.
Just look at what Cisco tried with the CPAK. While novel, didn't work out too well for them, and the customers that bought tons of them. But, fair point, CFP2 was still dithering, so...
We've seen the same with Apple, and how ship their devices with "unproven" tech. They've been lucky, so far...
Mark.
Current thread:
- Re: MSA’s and network architecture, (continued)
- Re: MSA’s and network architecture Mark Tinka (May 17)
- Re: MSA’s and network architecture Martin Hannigan (May 18)
- Re: MSA’s and network architecture Saku Ytti (May 17)
- Re: MSA’s and network architecture Etienne-Victor Depasquale via NANOG (May 17)
- Re: MSA’s and network architecture Saku Ytti (May 17)
- Re: MSA’s and network architecture Etienne-Victor Depasquale via NANOG (May 17)
- Re: MSA’s and network architecture Mark Tinka (May 18)
- Re: MSA’s and network architecture Saku Ytti (May 18)
- Re: MSA’s and network architecture Saku Ytti (May 17)
- Re: MSA’s and network architecture Mark Tinka (May 18)
- Re: MSA’s and network architecture Etienne-Victor Depasquale via NANOG (May 18)
- Re: MSA’s and network architecture Mark Tinka (May 20)
- Re: MSA’s and network architecture Mark Tinka (May 17)