nanog mailing list archives
Re: The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs
From: "Valdis Klētnieks" <valdis.kletnieks () vt edu>
Date: Thu, 02 Apr 2020 00:27:18 -0400
On Wed, 01 Apr 2020 20:58:17 -0700, Matt Corallo said:
If your goal is to force companies the world over to host domestically, where they follow local licensing regimes (yes, including censorship, as well as data access), itâs highly effective.
You missed the point. There's a distinction between "setting up conducive conditions" and "doing". Both may be morally problematic, but they're different things. Consider the US example of certain US companies who got caught giving the NSA a fiber connection at certain "interesting" points in the network - the legal exposure for the companies and for the intelligence agency were totally different. It's why our legal system recognizes the difference between committing a felony and being an accessory to the crime. We have *enough* trouble with people yelling "Censorship!" when Facebook or Quora or other social media sites owned by private actors enforce AUPs. Let's not let the word get further muddied into uselessness like "terrorism" has been over the last 2 decades.
Attachment:
_bin
Description:
Current thread:
- The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs Pengxiong Zhu (Apr 01)
- Re: The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs Ca By (Apr 01)
- Re: The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs Pengxiong Zhu (Apr 01)
- Re: The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs Ca By (Apr 01)
- Re: The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs Pengxiong Zhu (Apr 01)
- Re: The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs Matt Corallo (Apr 01)
- Re: The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs Pengxiong Zhu (Apr 01)
- Re: The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs Jay Hennigan (Apr 01)
- Re: The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs Valdis Klētnieks (Apr 01)
- Re: The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs Matt Corallo via NANOG (Apr 01)
- Re: The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs Valdis Klētnieks (Apr 01)
- Re: The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs Ca By (Apr 01)
- Re: The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs Tom Beecher (Apr 01)
- Re: The Cost of Paid Peering with Chinese ISPs Pengxiong Zhu (Apr 01)